ะงะธั‚ะฐะนั‚ะต ะบะฝะธะณะธ ะพะฝะปะฐะนะฝ ะฝะฐ Bookidrom.ru! ะ‘ะตัะฟะปะฐั‚ะฝั‹ะต ะบะฝะธะณะธ ะฒ ะพะดะฝะพะผ ะบะปะธะบะต

ะงะธั‚ะฐั‚ัŒ ะพะฝะปะฐะนะฝ ยซะšะพะผะผะตะฝั‚ะฐั€ะธะน ะะดะฒะตะฝั‚ะธัั‚ะพะฒ ะกะตะดัŒะผะพะณะพ ะ”ะฝั ะฝะฐ ะ•ะฒะฐะฝะณะตะปะธะต ะพั‚ ะ˜ะพะฐะฝะฝะฐยป. ะกั‚ั€ะฐะฝะธั†ะฐ 15

ะะฒั‚ะพั€ ะฝะตะธะทะฒะตัั‚ะตะฝ ะะฒั‚ะพั€

? 431 ัƒัŽั„ั” ั‚ ?ะ‡ั…ั‘ั… ั?ั‹ ั‘ัŽั‡ั„ั€ั ?ะั…ะ„ัˆั‰ ?ัŠั”ัŒั…ััˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ?ั…ะัŠัŽั‚ั?ั‰ ?ัŽััŽะ ั‘ ะŽั…ั‹โ„–? - ั”ะั…ัƒั”ั‹ัˆะัŽั‚ั€ะ„โ„– ยคะ„ัŽะ„ ั‘ััŽะ ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ?ัะ„ัˆัŽั—ัˆั‰ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัˆ ?ั‹ั…ัŠั‘ั€ัั„ะัˆั‰ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ยฐัŠัŽั‹ั€ัŒัˆ ัŒ?ยฐั‹ั…ััˆ . ?ัŽััŽะ ัŽั‘ั”ั„ัˆั‹ ?ั…ั‘ะ„ัŽะั€ ัˆ ั…ัƒัŽ ั”ัžั…ััˆั…, ััŽ ัั… ััŽั‘ัžัˆะ„ั€ั‹ ัั…ัŽัั—ัŽั„ัˆัŒ?ัŒ ั‚?ั„ั‚ัˆัั”ะ„โ„– ััŽั‚?ั‰ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ ั‚ั…ะ? ั‚ัŒั…ั‘ะ„ัŽ ?ัˆัŠั…ั‰ั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ั€. ?ั€ ยคะ„ัŽัŒ ั‘ัŽััŽะั… ัั… ั?ั‹ัŽ ัžะ„ัŽ-ั‹ัˆััŽ ะั…ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽ ั”ะั…ัƒั”ั‹ัˆะัŽั‚ั€ััŽ ัˆั‹ัˆ ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ัˆัƒัั”ะ„ัŽ; ัˆั‘ัŠั‹?ัžั€  ั…?? ััŽั‹ั…ั… ั”ั‚ั…ั‹ัˆัžัˆั‚ยฐัˆั‰ั‘  ะั€ั‡ั‹ั€ั„, ัˆ ััŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ั”??ั€  ััŽะโ„–ัั€ ัะัˆั ั‹ั€ ะ„ั€ัŠัˆั… ะั€ั‡ัŒั…ะ?, ัžะ„ัŽ ั‚ั‘ั… ั„ะั”ัƒัˆั… ั„ัŽัŠะ„ะัˆัั€ั‹โ„–ั?ั… ัะัŽัั‹ั…ัŒ? ั?ั‹ัˆ ัŽะ„ั‹ัŽั†ั…ั?.

?ัŽััŽะ‡ัˆั‡ัˆะ„ัˆั‡ัŒ

?ั€ัŠ ััŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆั… ?ะ‡ั…ั‘ั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัŽััŽะั€, ั‚ัŽั‡ััˆัŠั‹ั€ ั…?? ั„ะั”ัƒั€  ะ„ั…ัŽะัˆ , ัˆั‡ั‚ั…ั‘ะ„ัั€  ัŠั€ัŠ ?ัŽััŽะ‡ัˆั‡ัˆะ„ัˆั‡ัŒ ัˆั‹ัˆ ?ั‚ะ„ัˆั—ัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒ. ?ะ„ั€ ะ„ั…ัŽะัˆ  ั‚ัŽั‡ััˆัŠั‹ั€ ัˆ ั‚?ั„ั‚ัˆัั”ั‹ั€ั‘โ„–, ัžะ„ัŽั? ัˆั‡ั‹ัŽั†ัˆะ„โ„– ััŽั ะ„ัˆั… ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั…, ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัััŽ ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ัŽััŽั‹ัŽั†ััŽั… ?ั…ั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัŽัŒั”. ?ั‚ะ„ัˆั—ัˆั‰, ัƒั‹ั€ั‚ั?ั‰ ัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ัŠัŽั‚ั€ะ„ั…ั‹โ„– ยคะ„ัŽั‰ ะ„ั…ัŽะัˆัˆ, ั‡ั€ ั‚ั‹ ั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ัั…ะั‚ัŽัั€ัžั€ั‹โ„–ัั€  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€ ั?ั‹ั€ ัะั…ั‚ะั€?ั…ัั€ ั‚ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั”? ัะัˆะัŽั„ั” ัะัˆ ั‚ัŽัั‹ัŽ?ั…ััˆัˆ. ? ะั…ั‡ั”ั‹โ„–ะ„ั€ะ„ั… ัžั…ัƒัŽ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั€  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€ ัˆ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั€  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ัˆ ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„–? ัˆ ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„ัŽั‰. ?ั ัŽะ„ั‘ะ„ั€ัˆั‚ั€ั‹ ั…ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ั‘ั€ัŒัŽั‘ัŽั‡ัั€ััˆ  ััŽ ั„ัŽ ะ„ั€ัŠัŽั‰ ั‘ะ„ั…ัั…ััˆ ั‘ัŽั…ั„ัˆััˆั‹ ั‚ัŽั…ั„ัˆััŽ ยคะ„ัˆ ั„ั‚ั… ัะัˆะัŽั„?, ัžะ„ัŽ ัะั€ัŠะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆ ัƒัŽั‚ัŽะ , ัŽััˆ ััŽะ„ั…ะ ั‹ัˆ ั‘ั‚ัŽ? ัˆัั„ัˆั‚ัˆั„ั”ั€ั‹โ„–ัั”? ะ„ัŽั†ั„ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„–.

?ัŽั‡ั‚ั€ัั?ั‰ ั‚ 451 ัƒ. ?ั€ั‹ัŠัˆั„ัŽัั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ั‘ัŽััŽะ ั„ั‹  ะั€ั‘ั‘ัŒัŽะ„ะั…ััˆ  ั‚ัŽัะัŽั‘ั€ ัŽ ?ั…ั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒั… ัˆ ?ัŽััŽะ‡ัˆั‡ัˆะ„ัˆั‡ัŒั… ั‚?ัั…ั‘ ะั…ยฐั…ััˆั… ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ ัŽััŽัˆั—. ?ั€ัŠ ัั…ั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆั€ัั…, ะ„ั€ัŠ ัˆ ััŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ัŽั‚ั€ะ„ั…ั‹ัˆ ?ั‚ะ„ัˆั—ัˆ  ัŽะ„ั‚ั…ะัƒั‹ัˆ ะั…ยฐั…ััˆั… ั‘ัŽััŽะั€ ัˆ ัŽััŽั‘ััŽั‚ั€ั‹ัˆ ัั…ั‡ั€ั‚ัˆั‘ัˆัŒ?ั… ั‘ั…ัŠะ„? ั‚ ั‘ะั…ั„ั… ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ะ„ั‚ั€, ัŠั€ัŠ ั‚ ั‘ั‚ัŽ? ั‚ะั…ัŒ  ััŽั‘ะ„ั”ััˆั‹ ัˆ ?ะัˆั‰ ััŽั‹ั…ั… ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆั… ะ„ัŽัŒั” ัั€ั‡ั€ั„.

?ัŽััŽะ ั‚ ?ั€ั‹ัŠัˆั„ัŽัั… ััŽั„ะ„ั‚ั…ะั„ัˆั‹ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ ัŽ ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัั‘ะ„ั‚ั… ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€, ั‡ั€ ั‚ั‹  , ัžะ„ัŽ ?ั ั‘ัŽั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ ัŽั„ัั” ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ั‘ ?ะ„ะŽัŽัŒ, ัžะ„ัŽ ัŠั€ั‘ั€ั…ะ„ั‘  ?ัƒัŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ัˆ ัŽั„ัั” ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ั‘ ัั€ัŒัˆ, ัžะ„ัŽ ัŠั€ั‘ั€ั…ะ„ั‘  ?ัƒัŽ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„?, ัŠะัŽัŒั… ัƒะั…ั—ั€. ?ัŽั†ั„ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ัŠั€ั†ั„ัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ั?ั‹ั€ ั‘ัŽั—ะั€ัั…ัั€ ัˆ ั„ั‚ั… ยคะ„ัˆั— ัะัˆะัŽั„? ัะัŽั‚ัŽั‡ัƒั‹ั€ยฐั…ั? ัŠั€ัŠ ัŽะ„ั„ั…ั‹โ„–ั?ั…, ัั… ั‘ัŒั…ยฐั€ัั?ั…, ัั…ัˆั‡ัŒั…ัั?ั…, ัั…ั„ั…ั‹ัˆัŒ?ั…, ัั…ะั€ั‡ั‹ั”ัžั?ั…. ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั€ , ั€ ัั… ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั€  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ ั?ั‹ั€ ัะัˆั‡ัั€ัั€ ั‡ั€ ัŽั‘ััŽั‚ั” ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€. ?ัŽั‘ัŠัŽั‹โ„–ัŠั” ั€ ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ั‘ัŽั…ั„ัˆัั…ั? ั„ั‚ั… ัะัˆะัŽั„?, - ั‘ะ„ะั€ั„ั€ััˆั… ?ัŽัƒัŽัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠั€ ั?ั‹ัŽ ั‚ัŽัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัั” ัั…ั‡ัƒะั€ััˆัžั?ัŒ; ?ั ั‘ะ„ะั€ั„ั€ั‹ ั‚ ?ั‚ัŽั…ั‰ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰, ั€ ัั… ั‚ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„ั…, ัŽั„ัั€ัŠัŽ ัŠะั…ั‘ะ„ั?ั… ัŒั”ัŠัˆ ั?ั‹ัˆ ัั…ั‡ัƒะั€ััˆัžั?ัŒัˆ, ัˆััŽ ัˆ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ั?ั‹ั€ ัั…ั‡ัƒะั€ััˆัžััŽั‰. ?ัˆะ„ั€ั…ัŒ ัŠะั€ะ„ัŠัˆั… ั‚?ั‘ัŠั€ั‡?ั‚ั€ััˆ  ัˆั‡ ?ั€ั‹ัŠั…ั„ัŽัั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ั€ ั‚ั…ะ?:

"?ั€ะ„ั…ัŒ ัŒ?, ั‘ั‹ั…ั„ั”  ั‘ั‚ ะ„?ัŒ ัŽะ„ะŽั€ัŒ, ั„ั…ั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ั”  ั‘ ัŽั?ั…ัƒัŽ ั‘ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ัˆ , ั”ัžัˆัŒ ั‹?ั„ั…ั‰ ัˆั‘ััŽั‚ั…ั„?ั‚ั€ะ„โ„– ัŽั„ััŽัƒัŽ ัˆ ะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั†ั… ??ัั€, ัั€ยฐั…ัƒัŽ ?ัŽั‘ััŽั„ั€ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€, ะ„ั€ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั†ั… ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัััŽัƒัŽ ั‚ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัˆ ั‚ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„ั…; ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัััŽัƒัŽ ?ัŽัƒั€ ัˆ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัััŽัƒัŽ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠั€ ั‘ ัั‹ั€ัƒัŽะั€ั‡ั”ัŒััŽั‰ ั„ั”ยฐัŽั‰ ัˆ ะ„ั…ั‹ัŽัŒ; ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ั‘ ?ะ„ะŽัŽัŒ. ?ะ„ัŽ ัŠั€ั‘ั€ั…ะ„ั‘  ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ัˆ ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ั‘ ัั€ัŒัˆ, ัžะ„ัŽ ัŠั€ั‘ั€ั…ะ„ั‘  ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„?; ั‚ัŽ ั‚ั‘?ัŒ ััŽั„ัŽัััŽั‰ ัั€ัŒ, ัŠะัŽัŒั… ัƒะั…ั—ั€; ะัŽั†ั„?ัััŽัƒัŽ ัะั…ั†ั„ั… ั‚ั‘ั…ั— ั‚ั…ัŠัŽั‚ ั” ?ะ„ะŽั€, ั‘ัŽัŽะ„ั‚ั…ะ„ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ัˆ ั‚ ยคะ„ัˆ ััŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ััˆั… ั„ััˆ - ะั€ั„ัˆ ัั€ั‘ ัˆ ะั€ั„ัˆ ัั€ยฐั…ัƒัŽ ั‘ัั€ั‘ั…ััˆ  - ะัŽั„ัˆั‹ั‘  ัŽะ„ ั„ั…ั‚? ?ั€ะัˆัˆ, ัŒั€ะ„ั…ะัˆ ?ัŽั†ัˆั…ั‰, ั‘ัŽัŽะ„ั‚ั…ะ„ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„?; ัŽั„ััŽัƒัŽ ัˆ ะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั†ั… ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€, ??ัั€ ?ัŽั‘ััŽั„ั€, ัˆั‘ัŠั‹?ัžัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ะัŽั†ั„?ัััŽัƒัŽ, ั‚ ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽัŒ ัะัˆั‡ัั€?ัŒ ั„ั‚ั… ัะัˆะัŽั„?, ั‚ัั… ั‚ั‘ ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัŽัŒัั…ััˆ , ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั”??ัˆั— ัั…ัˆั‡ัŒั…ัััŽ, ัั…ะั€ั‡ั„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ, ัั…ะั€ั‡ั‹ั”ัžััŽ; ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžัˆั… ยคะ„ัˆั— ัะัˆะัŽั„ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ััˆ ั‚ ัŠัŽั…ัŒ ั‘ั‹ั”ัžั€ั… ัั… ัŒัŽั†ั…ะ„ ั?ะ„โ„– ั”ั‘ะ„ะั€ัั…ััŽ ััŽั‘ะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ ั‘ัŽ?ั‡ั€, ััŽ ั‘ัŠัŽะั…ั… ั‘ั‚ัŽั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ัŠั€ั†ั„ัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ั„ัŽั‹ั†ััŽ ั?ะ„โ„– ั‘ัŽั—ะั€ัั…ััŽ ัˆ ั„ั…ั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ะ„โ„– ั‘ัŽัŽั?ั€ ั‚ ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ัˆ ั‚ ัŽั„ััŽัŒ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ััˆัˆ" (?ัˆั‹ัˆัั ?ั€ะ‡ะ‡. "?ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹? ั‚ั…ะ? ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ัŒัˆะั€" ะ„. ั‘ะ„ะ 62).

? ะั…ั‡ั”ั‹โ„–ะ„ั€ะ„ั… ?ั€ั‹ัŠั…ั„ัŽัั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัŽััŽะั€ ัั€ ?ัŽั‘ะ„ัŽัŠั… ั‘ัŽั—ะั€ััˆั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ัั€ั‚ั‘ั…ัƒั„ั€ ัˆ ั…?? ััŽั‹ั…ั… ั”ั‘ัˆั‹ัˆั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ะั€ั‘ัŠัŽั‹?. ? ัŠัŽัะŽั… ัŠัŽัะŽัŽั‚, ัˆัŒัั…ะั€ะ„ัŽะ ?ั‘ะ„ัˆััˆั€ั, ั”ัั…ั†ั„?ัั?ั‰ ั‚ ะ„ัŽัŒ, ัžะ„ัŽ ัั…ั‡ัŽัั€ั‘ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ัˆัŒัั…ะัˆัˆ ะ„ะั…ัั”ั…ะ„ ั”ะั…ัƒั”ั‹ัˆะัŽั‚ั€ััˆ  ยคะ„ัŽั‰ ัะัŽัั‹ั…ัŒ? - ัั€ั‚ั‘ั…ัƒั„ั€ ั‡ั€ัŠะ?ั‹ ยฐัŠัŽั‹? ั‚ ?ัะ„ัˆัŽั—ัˆัˆ ัˆ ั‚ ?ั‹ั…ัŠั‘ั€ัั„ะัˆัˆ - ยคะ„ัˆั— ั„ั‚ั”ั— ะŽั…ัะ„ะั€ั— ั‘ััŽะั€. ?ั€ ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽัŒ ั‘ัŽััŽะั… ั‚ ?ัŽัั‘ะ„ั€ัะ„ัˆััŽััŽั‹ั… ั‚ 553 ัƒัŽั„ั” ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚โ„– ั‚?ัั…ั‘ั‹ั€ ะั…ยฐั…ััˆั… ัŽ ัั€ั‘ัˆั‹โ„–ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽัŒ ััŽั„ั€ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆัˆ ?ัŽััŽะ‡ัˆั‡ัˆะ„ัˆั‡ัŒั€, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั‰ ัะัˆั ั‹ ะ‡ัŽะัŒั” ััŽั‘ะ„ัŽ ัััŽัƒัŽ ะั€ั‘ัŠัŽั‹ั€ ัˆ ัŽั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั€ั‹ั‘  ั„ัŽ ะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ััˆ ั‚ ะ„ั€ัŠัˆั— ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัˆั— ั‘ั…ัŠะ„ั€ั— ัŠั€ัŠ ัˆั€ัŠัŽั‚ัˆะ„?, ัŠัŽัะ„? ัˆ ั€ัััˆั‘ัˆัะŽ?. ?ัŽั„ะ„ั‚ั…ะั„ัˆั‚ ?ั€ั‹ัŠั…ั„ัŽัั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ ั‚ั…ะ?, ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚โ„– ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ัˆัƒั‹ั€ ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹?ัััŽัƒัŽ ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžัˆ  ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ัŽะะ„ัŽั„ัŽัŠั‘ัˆั…ั‰ ัˆ ั…ะั…ั‘โ„–?.

?ัŽััŽะ‡ั…ั‹ัˆะ„ัˆั‡ัŒ

?ั‘? ั†ั… ัŽั„ัˆั ั‚ัŽัะัŽั‘ ัŽั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั€ั‹ั‘  ัั…ะั€ั‡ะั…ยฐ?ัั?ัŒ: "?ั‚ั… ัะัˆะัŽั„?, ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั€  ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั€  ัะัˆั‚ัŽั„ ะ„ั‘  ั‚ ั„ั…ั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆั… ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‚ัŽั‹ั…ั‰, ั”ัะั€ั‚ั‹ ??ั…ั‰ ั„ั‚ั”ัŒ  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ัŒัˆ, ัˆั‹ัˆ ั‚ั‘? ยคะ„ัŽ ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั€ั…ะ„ั‘  ั„ั‚ั”ัŒ  ั‚ัŽั‹ ัŒัˆ?" ?ัŽััŽะ‡ั…ั‹ัˆะ„? ั‘ัžัˆะ„ั€ั‹ัˆ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั”? ั‚ัŽั‹? ัƒัŽั‘ััŽั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ั”??ั…ั‰, ั€ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั”? ั‚ัŽั‹? - ะั€ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽะ?ัััŽั‰ ั‚ ัั…ั‰. ?ั€ ะ„ะั…ะ„โ„–ั…ัŒ ั‘ัŽััŽะั… ั‚ ?ัŽัั‘ะ„ั€ัะ„ัˆััŽััŽั‹ั… ั‚ 680 ัƒ. ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚โ„– ะั…ยฐัˆั‹ั€, ัžะ„ัŽ ั‚ัŽั‹  ั‘ัŠัŽะั…ั… ัŽะ„ััŽั‘ัˆะ„ั‘  ัŠ ั‚ัŽัะัŽั‘ั” ั„ั‚ั”ั— ัะัˆะัŽั„, ัžั…ัŒ ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ัˆ ั‚?ั‘ัŠั€ั‡?ั‚ั€ั‹ั€ั‘โ„– ั‚ ััŽั‹โ„–ั‡ั” ั„ั‚ั”ั— ั‚ัŽั‹ั…ั‰ ั‚ ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‚ัŽั‹ั…ั‚ัŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ. ?ะ„ัŽ ะั…ยฐั…ััˆั… ั‡ั€ั‚ั…ะยฐัˆั‹ัŽ ัŽะะ„ัŽั„ัŽัŠั‘ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽั… ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹ั…ััˆั… ัะัˆะัŽั„? ัˆ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ ั„ั‹  ?ั€ัั€ั„ััŽั‰ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ, ัˆ ัะัˆั‚ั…ั‹ั€ ั‡ั€ะ„ ัั”ั‚ยฐัˆั…ั‘  ?ะัˆััˆะ„ั€ะัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัˆั… ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ัŽัƒัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั… ั‘ััŽะ? ะ‡ัŽะัŒั€ั‹โ„–ััŽ ัŠ ัŠัŽัะŽั”. ?ะัˆัั‹ัˆั‡ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ั‚ 730 ัƒ. ?ัŽั€ัั ัˆั‡ ?ั€ัŒั€ั‘ัŠั€ ั‘ั”ัŒัŒัˆะัŽั‚ั€ั‹ ยคะ„ัˆ ั„ัŽัŠะ„ะัˆั? ั„ั‹  ?ัŽั‘ะ„ัŽัžััŽั‰ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ. ?ั€ัŠ ั„ั‹  ?ัŽั‘ะ„ัŽัžััŽั‰, ะ„ั€ัŠ ัˆ ั„ั‹  ?ั€ัั€ั„ััŽั‰ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ ะั…ยฐั…ััˆ  ั‘ัŽััŽะัŽั‚ ัะัˆั ั‹ัˆ ั‡ัั€ัžั…ััˆั… ั„ัŽัƒัŒั€ะ„ัŽั‚.

?ัŽ ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ัั€ ะั…ะ‡ัŽะัŒั€ะŽัˆัˆ

?ั…ะ‡ัŽะัŒั€ะŽัˆ  ัŽััั€ะั”ั†ัˆั‹ั€, ัžะ„ัŽ ัŠั€ัŠ ?ัˆัŒั‘ัŠั€ , ะ„ั€ัŠ ัˆ ัะัŽะ„ั…ั‘ะ„ั€ัะ„ั‘ัŠัˆั… ั‚ั…ะ„ั‚ัˆ ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ั‚ ัŽั‘ััŽั‚ััŽัŒ ั‘ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ั?, ัžะ„ัŽ ัŠั€ั‘ั€ั…ะ„ั‘  ะ„ะ?ั— ั‹ัˆะŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ัˆ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€. ?ัˆัŠั…ั‰ั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ัˆ ?ั€ั‹ัŠั…ั„ัŽัั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹? ั‚ั…ะ? ัŽัŠั€ั‡ั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ััŽั‹โ„–ยฐั…ั‰ ัžั€ั‘ะ„โ„–? ัะัˆั…ัŒั‹ั…ัŒ? ั„ั‹  ัŽััŽัˆั—. ??ะ„ั…ะ ั”ัžัˆั‹ ัŽ ั‚ั‡ั€ัˆัŒััŽัŒ ัŽััŒั…ัั… ั—ั€ะั€ัŠะ„ั…ะั?ัŒัˆ ัŽั‘ัŽัั…ัััŽั‘ะ„ ัŒัˆ ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ยคะ„ัˆัŒัˆ ั„ั‚ั”ัŒ  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ัŒัˆ, ะ„ั€ัŠัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ, ัžะ„ัŽั? ะ„ัŽ, ัžะ„ัŽ ั?ั‹ัŽ ัŽั‘ัŽัั…ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„–? ัŠั€ั†ั„ัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? - ั‘ะ„ั€ััŽั‚ัˆั‹ัŽั‘โ„– ัŽั?ั…ั‰ ั„ั‹  ัŽััŽัˆั—. ?ั‘? ัŽะ„ััŽั‘ ?ั…ั…ั‘  ัŠ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„ั… ั‚ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั… ั?ั‹ัŽ ัะัˆั‘ั‚ั€ัˆั‚ั€ั…ัŒัŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„ัŽั‰, ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั€  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ ั‚ัŽั‘ัะัˆััˆัŒั€ั‹ั€ ะ„ัŽ, ัžะ„ัŽ ัะัˆัั€ั„ั‹ั…ั†ั€ั‹ัŽ ัŠ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„ั…. ?ั…ะ‡ัŽะัŒั€ะŽัˆัŽัั?ั… ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ ััŽั„ัž?ะัŠัˆั‚ั€ั‹ัˆ ัŽั?ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ั‚ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั….

?ั‚ั€ ัั…ั‡ัั€ัžัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ั?ั— ะั…ะ‡ัŽะัŒั€ะŽัˆัŽัั?ั— ัั€ัะั€ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆ  ัŽะ„ั‹ัˆัžั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ัŽะ„ ััŽั‹ัŽั†ั…ััˆ , ัˆั‡ั‹ัŽั†ั…ัััŽัƒัŽ ั‚ ?ัˆัŠั…ั‰ั‘ัŠัŽัŒ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ั… ั‚ั…ะ?. ?ั…ะั‚?ัŒัˆ ัˆั‡ ััˆั— ั?ั‹ัˆ ั‘ัŽะŽัˆััˆั€ัั…, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ั‚ัŽั‡ะัŽั„ัˆั‹ัˆ ัŽั‘ััŽั‚ัั”? ัŒัŽัั€ะั—ัˆั‘ะ„ั‘ัŠั”? ัˆั„ั…?, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั€  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ ะ„ะ?ั— ั‹ัˆะŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ - ัั…ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆั†ัˆัŒั€. ?ัŽั‚ะั…ัŒั…ัั?ั‰ ั”ััˆะ„ั€ะัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒ ั”ั‚ั…ัŠัŽั‚ั…ัžัˆั‹ ยคะ„ัŽ ััŽั ะ„ัˆั…. ?ัŽ ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽัŒั” ัั€ัะั€ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆ? ัะัˆัั€ั„ั‹ั…ั†ั€ั‹ัˆ ั€ะัŒัˆััˆั€ัั…, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ั‚ ัั…ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽัŒ ัŽะ„ััŽยฐั…ััˆัˆ ั‚ัŽั‘ัะัˆั ั‹ัˆ ะ„ัŽัžัŠั” ั‡ะั…ััˆ , ััŽั„ัŽััั”? ัั…ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ัŒ ัั€ัˆััŽั‹ั…ั… ะั€ัััˆัŒ ั„ั‚ัˆั†ั…ััˆ ัŒ, ัžะ„ัŽ ??ั  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ััŽั„ัžัˆั?ัััŽั‰, ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽั‘ะ„ั…ัั…ัััŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„–? ััŽ ัŽะ„ััŽยฐั…ััˆ? ัŠ ?ะ„ะŽั”. ?ะ„ั€ ะ„ัŽัžัŠั€ ั‡ะั…ััˆ  ััŽั„ัŽัั?ัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ ัŽะ„ะั€ั†ั…ัั€ ั‚ ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžั?ั— ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัˆั— ั‘ั…ัŠะ„ั€ั—.

?ั„ั‚ั…ัะ„ัˆั‘ะ„? ั‘ั…ั„โ„–ัŒัŽัƒัŽ ั„ั 

?ัˆั‘ั€ะ„ั…ั‹ัˆ ัˆ ัˆั‡ั„ั€ะ„ั…ั‹ัˆ ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ัŠัŽัŒัŒั…ัะ„ั€ะัˆ  ัŽะ„ัŠะัŽั‚ั…ัััŽ ัˆ ัˆั‘ัŠะั…ัััŽ ัะัˆั‡ัั€?ะ„, ัžะ„ัŽ ั‚ ?ั‚ ?ั…ัั?ั— ?ัˆั‘ั€ััˆ ั— ัˆัŒั…?ะ„ั‘  ะ„ั€ั‰ั?, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ัะั…ั‚ัŽั‘ั—ัŽั„ ะ„ ั‚ัŽั‡ัŒัŽั†ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ัŽัƒะั€ััˆัžั…ัััŽัƒัŽ ััŽััˆัŒั€ััˆ  ัˆ ะ„ั€ัŠัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ ัั… ััŽั„ั„ั€?ะ„ั‘  ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹?ัััŽัŒั”, ะ„ัŽัžััŽัŒั” ัˆั‡ั‹ัŽั†ั…ััˆ? ัั€ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽัŒ  ั‡?ัŠั…. ?ัŽ?ั‡ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ั‚ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั…  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ัˆั‡ ะ„ั€ัŠัˆั— ะ„ั€ั‰ั. ?ะัˆ ะั€ั‘ั‘ัŒัŽะ„ะั…ััˆัˆ ะ„ั…ัŽั‹ัŽัƒัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั— ั‚ัŽัะัŽั‘ัŽั‚ ะ„ั€ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ะัŽั„ั€ ??? ั‚ั‘ั…ัƒั„ั€ ั‘ะ„ั€ะั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ัˆั‡ัั…ัƒั€ะ„โ„– ัะั…ั„ััŽั‹ัŽั†ั…ััˆั‰ ัˆ ยฐั€ะ„ัŠัŽัƒัŽ, ั—ัˆะ„ะัŽั‘ัั‹ั…ะ„?ัััŽัƒัŽ ะ‡ัˆั‹ัŽั‘ัŽะ‡ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ััˆ , ัžะ„ัŽั? ั‘ั‚ัŽัˆัŒัˆ ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ั€ัŒัˆ ั…?? ััŽั‹ั…ั… ัั… ั‡ั€ัั”ะ„ั€ะ„โ„– ยคะ„ัŽะ„ ั‚ัŽัะัŽั‘ (ั‘ัŒ. 8 ะ„. 279 ั‘ะ„ะ.). ?ั‘ั‹ัˆ ั‚ั„ัŽั—ััŽั‚ั…ัั?ั… ััˆั‘ั€ะ„ั…ั‹ัˆ ?ัˆัั‹ัˆัˆ ัั… ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ัˆั‹ัˆ  ั‘ััŽ ัŠั€ั†ั„ั”? ััŽั„ะัŽัััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัั?ั— ะ„ั€ั‰ั, ััŽัžั…ัŒั” ัั… ั‚ั„ัŽั—ััŽั‚ั…ัั?ั… ััˆั‘ั€ะ„ั…ั‹ัˆ ั?ะ„ั€?ะ„ั‘  ั‘ั„ั…ั‹ั€ะ„โ„– ยคะ„ัŽ? ?ั„ัั€ัŠัŽ ั‚ั„ัŽั—ััŽั‚ั…ััˆั… ัะั…ั„ั”ั‘ัŒัŽะ„ะั…ั‹ัŽ ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ั€ะ„ัŽัžััŽ ั‘ั‚ั…ั„ั…ััˆั‰, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ัŒัŽัƒั”ะ„ ััŽัŒัŽัžโ„– ัั€ัŒ ััŽั ะ„โ„– ั‚ ัั…ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽั‰ ั‘ะ„ั…ัั…ััˆ ะ„ั€ั‰ัั” ัั‹ั€ัั€ ั‘ัั€ั‘ั…ััˆ . ??? ั‚ั…ะ ะ„ ั‚:

1) ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ัˆั‹ัˆ ?ะัŽัˆะŽั”, ั‘ัŽั‘ะ„ัŽ ?ั”? ัˆั‡ ะ„ะ?ั— ั‹ัˆะŽ - ?ั…ัžััŽัƒัŽ ?ะ„ะŽั€, ?ัŽั‘ััŽั„ั€ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ - ??ัั€ ?ั…ัžััŽัƒัŽ ?ะ„ะŽั€ ัˆ ?ั‚ ะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ?ั”ั—ั€. (ั‘ัŒ. ?ะ‡. 28:19, ?ั. 1:1-2, 6:27, 14:16, 17, 26, ?ั… ััˆ  5:3, 4, ?ะ‡. 4:4-6, ?ั‚ะ. 1:1-3, 8, ั‘ัŒ. ัั€ ?ั. 1:1-3, 14).

"?ั‘ะ„โ„– ะ„ะัˆ ั†ัˆั‚?ั— ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ัั…ัั…ั‘ััŽั‰ ?ะัŽัˆะŽ?... ?ะ„ั…ะŽ, ??ั ัˆ ?ั‚ ะ„ัŽั‰ ?ั”ั—" (?ั‚ั€ััƒั…ั‹ัˆั‡ัŒ 615 ั‘ะ„ะ). ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ัˆ ?ะ„ั…ะŽ ั‘ั”ะ„โ„– "ัŽั„ััŽ ััŽ ัะัˆะัŽั„ั…, ั‚ ั—ั€ะั€ัŠะ„ั…ะั… ัˆ ั‚ ะŽั…ั‹ัˆ" (?ั€ะ„ะัˆั€ะั—ัˆ ัˆ ัะัŽะัŽัŠัˆ 34), ััŽ "ัั… ั‚ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ" (8 ะ„. 269 ั‘ะ. 9 ะ„. 68). ?ั‚ ะ„ัŽั‰ ?ั”ั— " ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ั‚ ะ„ั€ัŠัŽั‰ ั†ั… ัŒั…ะั… ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„–?, ัŠั€ัŠ ัˆ ?ัŽัƒ" (?ั‚ั€ััƒั…ั‹ัˆั… 616 ั‘ะ„ะ. ?ัŒ. ??? ?ัŽั. ัŒั€ะ„ั…ะัˆั€ั‹ ัั€ ?ัˆัŒ. 1:20-25).

2) ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ัˆ ัะั…ั„ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ััˆั… ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€. ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ั‚ ัั€ัˆั‚?ั‘ยฐั…ัŒ ัˆ ัั…ัŽัƒะั€ััˆัžั…ัััŽัŒ ั‘ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ั… ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ั€ - ั‚ ัะัˆะัŽั„ั…, ัŒั”ั„ะัŽั‘ะ„ัˆ, ั€ั‚ะ„ัŽะัˆะ„ั…ะ„ั… ัˆ ั‘ัˆั‹ั… (ั‘ัŒ. ?ั‘. 9:6, ?ัˆั—. 5:2, ?ั. 1:1-3, 8:58, 14:8-11, ?ัŽั‹ 1:15-17, 2:9, ?ั‚ะ. 1:8, ั‘ัŒ. ัั€ ?ัˆั—. 5:2, ?ะ‡. 11:1, 23, ?ัŠ. 1:35, ?ั. 16:23, ?ั‹ั. 2:6-8, ?ัŽั‹. 2:9).

"?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ัะั…ั„ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั”??ัˆัŒ, ั‘ั€ัŒัŽั?ะ„ั?ัŒ ??ััŽัŒ ?ัŽั†ัˆัˆัŒ... ?ัˆัŠัŽัƒั„ั€ ัั… ั?ั‹ัŽ ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ััˆ, ัŠัŽัƒั„ั€ ั? ?ั ัั… ั?ั‹ ั‚ ะ„ั…ั‘ััŽัŒ, ัั‹ัˆั‡ัŠัŽัŒ ัŽั?ั…ััˆัˆ ั‘ ั‚ั…ัžั?ัŒ ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ... ?ั ั?ั‹ ะั€ั‚ั?ั‰ ั‘ ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ, ัั…ั‡ัƒะั€ััˆัžั?ั‰ ัˆ ั‚ั‘ั…ัŒัŽัƒั”?ัˆั‰" (?ั‚ั€ััƒั…ั‹ัˆั… 615 ั‘ะ. ?? 469, 470; ?ั‚ั€ััƒั…ั‹ัˆั… 614, ??. 38, 63 ั‘ะ„ะ.).

"?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ั?ั‹ ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ััŽ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั” ัˆ ั‚ ัั€ัˆั‚?ั‘ยฐั…ัŒ ั‘ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ั…. ?ั ั?ั‹ ั‘ ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ัŽะ„ ั‚ั‘ั…ั‰ ั‚ั…ัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ, ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ัั€ั„ ั‚ั‘ั… ัั‹ั€ัƒัŽั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัั?ั‰, ัั€ั‚ั‘ั…ัƒั„ั€, ัั€ั‚ั…ัŠัˆ ั‚ั…ัžั?ั…, ?ัŽั‘ััŽั„โ„– ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘, ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัั?ั‰ ??ั ?ัŽั†ัˆั‰ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ั‹ ัŽะ„ ั‚ั…ัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ,  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ัŽะ„ั„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„–?, ั‚ั‘? ั†ั… - ัŽั„ััŽ ั‘ ?ะ„ะŽัŽัŒ" (??? Review and Herald. 5 ั€ัะั…ั‹  1906 ัƒ., ั‘ะ. ?? 19. ?ัŒ. ั„ัŽั. ัŒั€ะ„ั…ะัˆั€ั‹ ัั€ ?ั. 1:1-3, 14, ?ัŽั‹. 2:9, 3:10).

3) ? ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั”? ัะัˆะัŽั„ั” ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€. ?ัŽั‘ััŽั„โ„– ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ั?ั‹ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัััŽั‰ ัˆ ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัััŽั‰ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„–?, ััŽั„ัŽัััŽ ั„ะั”ัƒัˆัŒ ั‹?ั„ ัŒ, ั‚ัŽ ั‚ั‘ั…ั— ัŽะ„ััŽยฐั…ััˆ ั—, ั‡ั€ ัˆั‘ัŠั‹?ัžั…ััˆั…ัŒ ะ„ัŽัƒัŽ, ัžะ„ัŽ "?ั ัั… ััŽั‡ัั€ั‹ ัƒะั…ั—ั€" (2 ?ัŽะ. 5:21. ?ัŒ. ?ัŠ. 24:39, ?ั. 1:14, ?ัˆัŒ. 1:3, 4, 5:15, ?ั€ั‹. 4:4, ?ั‹ั. 2:7, 1 ?ัˆัŒ. 2:5, ?ั‚ะ. 2:14, 17, 1 ?ั. 1:1, 4:2, 2 ?ั. 7. ?ัŒ. ัั€ ?ะ‡. 1:23, ?ั. 1:14, ?ั‹ั. 2:6-8).

"?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ั?ั‹ ะั…ั€ั‹โ„–ั?ัŒ, ั„ั…ั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ั?ัŒ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠัŽัŒ" (??? ?ัั‘ะ„ะั”ัŠะ„ัŽะ ัŒัŽั‹ัŽั„?ั†ัˆ. 13 ัŽัŠะ„ ัะ  1898 ัƒ.). "?ััŽั‹ัั… ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั?ัŒ, ั‘ ัžั…ะะ„ั€ัŒัˆ, ั‘ั‚ัŽั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัั?ัŒัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠั”" (??? ?ัั€ัŒั…ััˆั… ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ััˆ. 17 ัˆ?ั  1897 ัƒ.) "ั”ัžั€ั‘ะ„ััˆัŠัŽัŒ ัั€ยฐั…ั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„?" (??? Review and Herald. 18 ะ‡ั…ั‚ะั€ั‹  1890 ัƒ.). "?ั  ั‚ัˆั‹ั‘  ัŠั€ัŠ ัั…ั‘ััŽัŒัŽ?ั?ั‰ ัŒั‹ั€ั„ั…ัั…ะŽ, ัˆัŒั…  ะ„ั” ั†ั… ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั”? ัะัˆะัŽั„ั”, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะั”? ัŒ? ััŽั‘ัˆัŒ, " (??? ?ั”ัŠัŽััˆั‘โ„– 21 1895 ัƒ.) ัˆ ัŠั€ัŠ ัžั‹ั…ั ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั‘ั…ัŒโ„–ัˆ, ?ั ั?ั‹ ั‘ัŒั…ะะ„ั?ัŒ (??? Review and Herald 4 ั‘ั…ัะ„ ัะ  1900 ัƒ.). "?ั ัŒัŽั‹ัˆั‹ั‘  ัŽ ?ั‚ัŽัˆั— ั”ัžั…ััˆัŠั€ั— ัˆ ัŽ ?ั…ัั… ?ั€ัŒัŽัŒ, ะ„ั€ัŠัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ ัŽะ„ัŽั†ั„ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั‹   ?ั…ั  ั‘ ัั€ยฐัˆัŒัˆ ัั”ั†ั„ั€ัŒัˆ, ัั€ยฐัˆัŒัˆ ั‘ั‹ั€ััŽั‘ะ„ ัŒัˆ ัˆ ัั…ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ั€ะ„ัŠั€ัŒัˆ" (2 ะ„. 508. ?ะ. ?ั‹ั”ั†ั…ััˆั… ัˆั‘ะŽั…ั‹ั…ััˆ  422. ?ัŒ. ??? ?ัŽั. ัŒั€ะ„ั…ะัˆั€ั‹ ัั€ ?ั. 1:1-3, 14, ?ัŽั‹. 1:26, 27, ?ั‚ะ. 2:14-18).