ะงะธั‚ะฐะนั‚ะต ะบะฝะธะณะธ ะพะฝะปะฐะนะฝ ะฝะฐ Bookidrom.ru! ะ‘ะตัะฟะปะฐั‚ะฝั‹ะต ะบะฝะธะณะธ ะฒ ะพะดะฝะพะผ ะบะปะธะบะต

ะงะธั‚ะฐั‚ัŒ ะพะฝะปะฐะนะฝ ยซะšะพะผะผะตะฝั‚ะฐั€ะธะน ะะดะฒะตะฝั‚ะธัั‚ะพะฒ ะกะตะดัŒะผะพะณะพ ะ”ะฝั ะฝะฐ ะ•ะฒะฐะฝะณะตะปะธะต ะพั‚ ะ˜ะพะฐะฝะฝะฐยป. ะกั‚ั€ะฐะฝะธั†ะฐ 14

ะะฒั‚ะพั€ ะฝะตะธะทะฒะตัั‚ะตะฝ ะะฒั‚ะพั€

?ะ„ัŽั? ั‡ั€?ัˆะ„ัˆะ„โ„– ั‘ั‚ัŽั‰ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ ัŽ ั…ั„ัˆััŽััŽั†ัˆัˆ, ั„ัˆัั€ัŒัˆั‘ะ„? ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัััŽ ัŽะ„ั‚ั…ะัƒั€ั‹ัˆ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€, ?ัŽะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ัŽััˆ ั‘ัžัˆะ„ั€ั‹ัˆ ั‡ั€ ัะัŽั‘ะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠั€, ัˆั‡ัะั€ัััŽัƒัŽ ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ัŠั€ัŠ ?ั…ั‘ั‘ัˆ? ัˆ ั‚ัŽั‡ั‚?ยฐั…ัััŽัƒัŽ ั„ัŽ ั”ะัŽั‚ั  ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€. ?ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ััŽ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ั” ัŽั„ััŽัƒัŽ ัˆั‡ ัŽะ„ั‚ั…ะ„ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆั‰ ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั”ัžั…ััˆ  - ั€ั„ัŽัะŽัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒั€, ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ัˆัƒ ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ัˆ ั?ั‹ ั”ั‘?ััŽั‚ั‹?ั ัŠั€ัŠ ??ั ?ัŽั†ัˆั‰ ัะัˆ ?ัƒัŽ ัŠะั…?ั…ััˆัˆ.

?ัŽั„ั€ั‹ัˆั‘ะ„? ั”ัžัˆั‹ัˆ, ัžะ„ัŽ ั…ั„ัˆั?ั‰ ?ัŽัƒ ัŽะ„ัŠะ?ั‚ั€ั‹ ?ั…ั  ั‚ ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžั?ั— ั‚ัˆั„ั€ั—, ัŽะ„ะัˆะŽั€  ัŠั€ัŠัŽั…-ั‹ัˆััŽ ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžัˆั… ั‚ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ ั—, ัŽััˆ ัŽะ„ัŠั€ั‡?ั‚ั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ัŽะ„ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ั€ ั‚ ะ„ะัˆั…ั„ัˆัั”? ัะัˆะัŽั„ั” ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ั‚ ะŽั…ั‹ัŽัŒ. ?ััˆ ัะัˆั‡ัั€ั‚ั€ั‹ัˆ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆััั”? ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ัŠั€ัŠ ?ะ„ะŽั€, ะ„ั€ัŠ ัˆ ??ัั€, ััŽ ั‘ัั…ยฐัˆั‹ัˆ ัŽัยท ั‘ััˆะ„โ„–, ัžะ„ัŽ ยคะ„ัˆ ั„ั‚ั€ ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹ั…ััˆ  ัŠั€ั‘ั€?ะ„ั‘  ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ัˆ ะ„ัŽั‰ ั†ั… ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ. ?ะ„ัŽะ„ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ ัˆััŽัƒั„ั€ ัั€ั‡?ั‚ั€?ะ„ ัั€ะ„ะัˆัั€ั‘ั‘ัˆัŽััˆั‡ัŒัŽัŒ, ััŽั‘ัŠัŽั‹โ„–ัŠั” ั‘ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ััŽ ัˆั— ัะั…ั„ััŽั‹ัŽั†ั…ััˆ , ?ะ„ั…ะŽ ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ ??ััŽัŒ ัะัˆ ั‚ัŽัั‹ัŽ?ั…ััˆัˆ ัˆ ั‚ััŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆัˆ ั‘ะ„ะั€ั„ั€ั‹ ัˆ ั”ัŒั…ะ ัŠั€ัŠ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘. ?ัŽั„ัŽัั?ัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ, ัะัˆ ั‚ัŽั‘ัŠะั…ั‘ั…ััˆัˆ ??ั ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ ?ั‚ ะ„?ัŒ ?ั”ั—ัŽัŒ. ?ัŽ ัˆัŒั…ััˆ ัั€ัˆััŽั‹ั…ั… ัˆั‡ั‚ั…ั‘ะ„ััŽัƒัŽ ัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ัŠัŽั‚ั€ะ„ั…ั‹  ยคะ„ัŽั‰ ะ„ั…ัŽะัˆัˆ ?ั€ั‚ั…ั‹ั‹ัˆ , ยคะ„ั€ ะ„ัŽัžัŠั€ ั‡ะั…ััˆ  ัั€ั‡?ั‚ั€ั…ะ„ั‘  ะ„ั€ัŠั†ั… ั‘ั€ั‚ั…ั‹ั‹ัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒัŽัŒ. ?ั€ั‚ั…ั‹ั‹ัˆั€ัั… ัะัˆั„ั…ะั†ัˆั‚ั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ั€, ัžะ„ัŽ ัˆัŒั…ัั€ ะ„ะ?ั— ั‹ัˆะŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ั?ั‹ัˆ ัะัŽั‘ะ„ัŽ ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹ั…ััˆ ัŒัˆ, ััŽั‘ะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั— ัŽั„ัั€ ัˆ ะ„ั€ ั†ั… ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั€  ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั€ั‹ั€ ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžั?ั… ั‚ั‘ั…ัŽัยทั…ัŒั‹??ัˆั… ะ‡ั”ััŠะŽัˆัˆ. ?ั€ัŠัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ, ัะั…ั†ั„ั… ั‚ัŽัั‹ัŽ?ั…ััˆ  ยคะ„ั€ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั€  ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ั?ั‹ั€ ?ะ„ะŽัŽัŒ; ัะัˆ ั‚ัŽัั‹ัŽ?ั…ััˆัˆ ?ะ„ั…ะŽ ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ ??ััŽัŒ; ั€ ัะัˆ ั‚ัŽั‘ัŠะั…ั‘ั…ััˆัˆ - ??ั ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ ?ั‚ ะ„?ัŒ ?ั”ั—ัŽัŒ. ? ัั€ัžั€ั‹ั… ะ„ะั…ะ„โ„–ั…ัƒัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ  ?ั…ะะ„ั”ั‹ั‹ัˆั€ั ัŽัะัŽั‚ั…ะัƒ ั”ัžั…ััˆั… ัŒัŽัั€ะั—ัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‚-ัŒัŽั„ั€ั‹ัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‚, ััŽั„ัž?ะัŠัˆั‚ั€  ัŠั€ัŠ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ??ัั€ ?ัŽั†ัˆ , ะ„ั€ัŠ ัˆ ั…ั„ัˆััŽััŽั†ัˆั…, ัŽั„ัั€ัŠัŽ ัŽั ัะั…ั„ััŽั‹ั€ัƒั€ั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ั?ั‹ ััŽั„ัžัˆั?ั ัั€ั„ั‹ั…ั†ั€?ัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ ?ัŽัƒั”, ัžะ„ัŽ ั‚ััŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆัˆ ัˆ ัะัŽ ั‚ัˆั‹ัŽั‘โ„– ั‚ ัˆั‡ั‚ั…ั‘ะ„ััŽั‰ ะ„ั…ัŽะัˆัˆ ััŽ ัˆัŒั…ััˆ ั‘ั”ััŽะั„ัˆัั€ะŽัˆัŽััˆั‡ัŒ ัˆั‹ัˆ ััŽั„ัžัˆัั…ััˆั…...

?ะัˆัั‹ัˆั‡ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ั‚ ั‘ะั…ั„ัˆัั… ะ„ะั…ะ„โ„–ั…ัƒัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ  ?ะัˆัƒั…ั ั‚?ั„ั‚ัˆัั”ั‹ ะ„ั…ัŽะัˆ? ัŽ ั‚ั…ัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ะัŽั„ั€ (ะ„.ั…. ัžะ„ัŽ ั‚ ัŠัŽัะŽั… ัŠัŽัะŽัŽั‚ ั‚ั‘ั…, ั„ั€ั†ั… ั‘ั€ะ„ั€ัั€ ัŽัžัˆั‘ะ„ ะ„ั‘  ัˆ ั‚ัŽั‡ั‚ะั€ะ„ ะ„ั‘  ัŠ ?ัŽัƒั”. ?ัŒ. ัˆั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆ? ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ, ?ั”ััŠ, ั‘ะ„ะ. 96), ั‘ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ััŽ ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽั‰ ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ัŠัŽ ?ะ„ั…ะŽ  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ั‚ ัั€ัˆั‚?ั‘ยฐั…ัŒ ั‘ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ั… ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ั€. ??ั ั‘ัŽั”ัžั€ั‘ะ„ััˆัŠ ั‚ั…ัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ั‚ัŒั…ั‘ะ„ั… ั‘ ?ะ„ะŽัŽัŒ, ััŽ ?ัŽัƒ ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ัŠัŽ ั‚ ัะัŽัˆั‡ั‚ัŽั„ััŽัŒ ั‘ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ั…, ัŠั€ัŠ ั”ั†ั… ัะัŽัˆั‘ั—ัŽั„ ?ัˆั‰ ัŽะ„ ั„ะั”ัƒัŽัƒัŽ. ?ะัˆัƒั…ั ั‚ั…ะัˆั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ั„ั”ยฐั€ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€, ััŽั„ัŽัััŽ ั‚ั‘ั…ัŒ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆัŒ ั„ั”ยฐั€ัŒ, ัŠั€ัŠ ัŽั ัŽยฐัˆััŽัžััŽ ัะั…ั„ััŽั‹ั€ัƒั€ั‹ - ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ั‹ั€ ั”ั†ั… ะั€ัโ„–ยฐั…, ััŽ ััŽ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั” ั?ั‹ั€ ัŽะ„ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‰ ัŽะ„ ั‚ั‘ั…ั— ั„ะั”ัƒัˆั— - ัžัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‰ ัˆ ัั… ัั€ั‚ยฐั…ั‰. ?ัŽัƒัŽั‘ ัˆั‹ัˆ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั… ?ั‹ัŽั‚ัŽ, ัะั…ั‚ะั€ะ„ัˆั‹ัŽั‘โ„– ั‚ ัะัŽัžั?ั‰ ัั…ะั€ั‡ะ?ั‚ั?ั‰ ั‘ัŽ?ั‡ ั‘ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั„ั”ยฐัŽั‰ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€. ?ั…ั‹ั€  ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžัˆั… ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” "?ั…ัŽั‘" ("?ัŽัƒ" - ัั…ั‡ ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹?ัััŽัƒัŽ ั€ะะ„ัˆัŠั‹ ) ัˆ "?ัŽ ?ั…ัŽั‘" ("?ัŽัƒ" - ั‘ ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹?ัั?ัŒ ั€ะะ„ัˆัŠั‹ั…ัŒ) ั‚ ?ั. 1:1, ?ะัˆัƒั…ั ั‡ั€ัŠั‹?ัžัˆั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ??ั ัั…  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ั‚ ัƒั‹ั€ั‚ััŽัŒ ัˆ ั€ัั‘ัŽั‹?ะ„ััŽัŒ ั‘ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ั…, ััŽ ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ั‹ัˆยฐโ„– ััŽั‘ะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ ัŽั?ั…ััˆ , ััŽั„ัžัˆั?ัััŽัƒัŽ ััŽ ะั€ััƒั” ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽั… ัŒัŽั†ััŽ ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹ัˆะ„โ„– ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ัŽัŒ "?ั…ัŽั‘", ััŽ ัั… "?ัŽ ?ั…ัŽั‘". ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘, ะ„ั€ัŠัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ, ั?ั‹ ัั…ัžะ„ัŽ ั‘ะั…ั„ัั…ั… ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ั‘ัŽะ„ั‚ัŽะ?ัั?ัŒัˆ ัˆ ัั…ั‘ัŽะ„ั‚ัŽะ?ัั?ัŒัˆ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ัŒัˆ. ?ัŽั‘ั…ัŒั” ?ะัˆัƒั…ัั€ ัŒัŽั†ััŽ ัั€ั‡ั‚ั€ะ„โ„– ัŽะ„ะŽัŽัŒ ?ะัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒั€.

?ะัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒ (ั€ะัˆั€ัั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ)

? ัั€ัžั€ั‹ั… ัžั…ะ„ั‚?ะะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ  ?ะัˆั‰, ัะั…ั‘ั‚ัˆะ„ั…ะ ?ั‹ั…ัŠั‘ั€ัั„ะัˆั‰ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ ัะัˆั ั‹ ะ„ั…ัŽะัˆ? ?ะัˆัƒั…ัั€ ัŽ ?ัŽัƒัŽั‘ั…, ั‡ั€ ัˆั‘ัŠั‹?ัžั…ััˆั…ัŒ ะ‡ั€ัŠะ„ั€, ัžะ„ัŽ ัŽั ัŽะ„ะัˆะŽั€ั‹ ัŠั€ัŠั”?-ั‹ัˆััŽ ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ััŽั‘ะั…ั„ััˆัžั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ัˆ ั‘ัŽั‡ั„ั€ัั?ัŒัˆ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ัŒัˆ. ?ั‡ ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ัŽั ั‡ั€ัŠั‹?ัžัˆั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ??ั ัั… ั?ั‹ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ ั‚ ั‹?ััŽัŒ ั‘ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ั… ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ั€, ััŽ ั‚ ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹?ัััŽัŒ ั‘ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ั… - ั‘ัŽั‡ั„ั€ัั?ัŒ ั†ัˆั‚?ัŒ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ, ั—ัŽะ„  ัˆั‘ัŠั‹?ัžัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ัั€ัˆั‚?ั‘ยฐัˆัŒ ัˆ ัั…ะั‚?ัŒ ัˆั‡ ั‚ั‘ั…ั— ัˆ ัžะ„ัŽ ััŽยคะ„ัŽัŒั” "ั?ั‹ัŽ (ั‚ะั…ัŒ ), ัŠัŽัƒั„ั€ ?ัƒัŽ ัั… ั?ั‹ัŽ". ?ั ั”ัžัˆั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ั?ั‹ั€ ั‹ัˆยฐโ„– ?ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั€  ?ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„– - ?ะ„ั…ะŽ, ัŠ ?ัŽะ„ัŽะัŽัŒั” ัŒัŽั†ััŽ ัŽะ„ัั…ั‘ะ„ัˆ ั‘ั‚ัŽั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ััˆ  ัั… ัŽะ„ััŽั‘ ?ัˆั…ั‘  ัŠ ัŠั€ัŠัŽัŒั”-ั‹ัˆััŽ ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ััˆ, ะ„. ั…. ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ัŠัŽ ?ั ัŽั„ัˆั  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ั‚ั…ัžั?ัŒ ัˆ ัžะ„ัŽ ?ั ั‘ัŽั‡ั„ั€ั‹ ??ัั€ ัˆั‡ ััˆัžั…ัƒัŽ ัˆ ัžะ„ัŽ ัะั…ั†ั„ั… ั„ัŽ ?ัƒัŽ ั‡ั€ะัŽั†ั„ั…ััˆ  ััŽั‘ะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ ั‚ัŽั‹ัˆ ?ัƒัŽ ?ะ„ะŽั€ - ??ั ัั… ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ั‹. ?ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ััŽ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ั” ?ะัˆ , ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ัั… ั?ั‹ ััˆ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัั?ัŒ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠัŽัŒ, ัˆััŽ ัั… ัˆัŒั…ั‹ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั„ั”ยฐัˆ ัˆ ัั… ั?ั‹ ะ„ั€ัŠั†ั… ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัั?ัŒ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ, ัˆััŽ ัั… ัˆัŒั…ั‹ ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ัˆ ั‘ั‚ัŽั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ ?ัŽัƒั€. ?ั ั?ั‹ ัะัŽั‘ะ„ัŽ ััŽั‹ั…ั… ั‚ัŽั‡ั‚?ยฐั…ัั?ัŒ, ัžั…ัŒ ั‚ั‘ั… ั‘ัŽั‡ั„ั€ัั?ั… ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€. ?ั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั€  ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€ ั?ั‹ั€ ัˆั‡ัะั€ัั€ ั‘ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ััŽ ัะัŽั‚ัˆั„ั…ััˆ  ?ัŽั†โ„–ั…ัƒัŽ ัŽ ?ัƒัŽ ะ„ะัˆั”ัŒะ‡ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽั‰, ััŽัั…ั„ััŽั‰ ั†ัˆั‡ััˆ - ัžะ„ัŽั? ั?ะ„โ„– ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽัŒ ัˆั‹ัˆ ?ั…ั‘ั‘ัˆั…ั‰. ?ั€ ัั…ะั‚ัŽัŒ ั‘ัŽััŽะั… ั‚ ?ัˆัŠั…ั…, ั‘ัŽั‡ั‚ั€ัััŽัŒ ั‚ 325 ัƒ. ั„ั‹  ะั…ยฐั…ััˆ  ั‘ััŽะั?ั— ััŽั‹ัŽั†ั…ััˆั‰ ?ะัˆ , ั‚?ั‘ะ„ั”ััˆั‹ ?ะ‡ั€ัั€ั‘ัˆั‰, ัŠั€ัŠ "ัŽะ„ั…ะŽ ัะั€ั‚ัŽั‚ั…ะัˆ ", ั”ะ„ั‚ั…ะั†ั„ั€ , ัžะ„ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ั‚ั‘ั…ัƒั„ั€ ั?ั‹ ัˆ ัžะ„ัŽ ?ั ัะัˆยฐ?ั‹ ัั… ัˆั‡ ัะั…ั„ยฐั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั”??ั…ัƒัŽ ัั…ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ััˆ , ััŽ ัˆั‡ ยคะ„ัŽั‰ ัˆั‘ัŠั‹?ัžัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽั‰ ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ, ัŠั€ัŠ ัˆ ?ะ„ั…ะŽ. ?ะัˆัŒั…ััˆั‚ ะ„ั…ะัŒัˆั "ั—ัŽัŒัŽั”ั‡ัˆัŽั‘" - ั…ั„ัˆััŽั‘ั”?ั?ั‰ - ัŠัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั”, ั‘ัŽััŽะ ััŽั„ะ„ั‚ั…ะั„ัˆั‹ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ ?ะ‡ั€ัั€ั‘ัˆ , ัžะ„ัŽ ัŽั ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ ัˆั‡ ั‘ั…ั  ัŽั„ัั” ัˆ ะ„ั” ั†ั… ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„โ„–, ัŠั€ัŠ ัˆ ?ะ„ั…ะŽ. ?ัŽัŒัŽั”ั‡ัˆัŽั‘ ัั…ั‹โ„–ั‡  ััŽััˆัŒั€ะ„โ„– ั„ะั”ัƒัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ. ?ัŽััŽะ ัะั…ั„ั€ั‹ ั€ัั€ะ‡ั…ัŒั… ัŠั€ัŠ ?ะัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒ, ะ„ั€ัŠ ัˆ ?ั€ั‚ั‚ั…ั‹ัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒ, ัŠั€ัŠ ั„ั‚ั€ ัƒั‹ั€ั‚ั?ั— ัŽะ„ัŠั‹ัŽัั…ััˆ  ัŽะ„ ะ„ัŽัžััŽั‰ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั? ัˆ ัะัŽั‚ัŽั‡ัƒั‹ั€ั‘ัˆั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ยคะ„ัŽ ัั…  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ัŽะ„ะัˆะŽั€ััˆั…ัŒ ั…ั„ัˆััŽััŽั†ัˆ , ัŠัŽัƒั„ั€ ัŽััŽ ั‡ั€?ัˆ?ั€ั…ะ„ ะ„ะัˆ ั‹ัˆะŽั€ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ัˆ ะ„ั€ัŠั†ั… ัั…  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ัŽะ„ะัˆะŽั€ััˆั…ัŒ ั‹ัˆะŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€, ัŠัŽัƒั„ั€ ัŽััŽ ั”ะ„ั‚ั…ะั†ั„ั€ั…ะ„ ั…ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ. ?ั€ัŠัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ, ?ัˆัŠั…ั‰ั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ ั‚ั…ะ? ั‡ั€ ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„, ัžะ„ัŽ "??ั ะัŽั†ั„?ั ?ะ„ะŽัŽัŒ... ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ?ะ„ะŽั€, ?ัŽัƒ ัŽะ„ ?ัŽัƒั€, ั‘ั‚ั…ะ„ ัŽะ„ ั‘ั‚ั…ะ„ั€, ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัั?ั‰ ?ัŽัƒ ัŽะ„ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัััŽัƒัŽ ?ัŽัƒั€ ะัŽั†ั„?ัั?ั‰, ัั… ั‘ัŽะ„ั‚ัŽะ?ัั?ั‰, ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ ??ัˆั‰ ัŽั„ัั” ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ั‘ ?ะ„ะŽัŽัŒ" (ะŽัˆะ„ัˆะัŽั‚ั€ััŽ ?ัˆั‹ัˆัััŽัŒ ?ั€ะ‡ะ‡ ั‚ "?ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ั… ั‚ั…ะ? ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ัŒัˆะั€" ะ„. 1 ั‘ะ„ะ. 29). ?ะ„ัŽะ„ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ ั‚ั…ะ? ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ ะั…ยฐั€??ัˆัŒ ัˆั‘ั?ะ„ั€ััˆั…ัŒ ัˆั‘ััŽั‚ั…ั„ั”??ัˆั— ะ„ะัˆััˆะ„ั€ะัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัŽั… ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆั… ัŽ ั‚ั…ะั….

?ะัˆั€ัั… ัŽะ„ั‚ั…ะัƒั‹ัˆ ะั…ยฐั…ััˆั… ั‘ัŽััŽะั€ ัˆ ั”ัŠั‹ัŽััˆั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ั‚ ะั€ั‘ัŠัŽั‹, ัˆ ัั€ ัะัŽะ„ ั†ั…ััˆัˆ ัŒััŽัƒัˆั— ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆั‰ ั€ะัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒ ั„ัŽัŠั€ั‡ั€ั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ัŽั  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ัั€ัˆััŽั‹ั…ั… ัƒะัŽั‡ั?ัŒ ัˆ ั‘ะ„ะั€ยฐั?ัŒ ั‚ะั€ัƒัŽัŒ ?ัˆัŒัŽัŠั€ะ„ัŽั‹ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ (ั‘ัŒ. ัั€ ?ั€ั. 7:8). ?ะั”ััั€, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะั€  ั‚?ั„ั…ั‹ัˆั‹ั€ั‘โ„– ััŽั‘ั‹ั… ัั…ะั‚ัŽัƒัŽ ?ัˆัŠั…ั‰ั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัŽััŽะั€ ัˆััŽัƒั„ั€ ัั€ั‡?ั‚ั€ั…ัŒั€  ััŽั‹ั”ั€ะัˆั€ัั€ัŒัˆ, ะ„ั€ัŠั†ั… ะ„ะั…ั‚ัŽั†ัˆั‹ั€ ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚โ„–. ?ั‹?ัžั…ั‚ัŽั… ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ัŽ ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั„ั‚ัˆั†ั…ััˆ  ั—ัŽัŒัŽั”ั‡ัˆัŽั‘, ััŽั‘ะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ัŽััˆ ัˆั‡ัŽัะั€ั†ั€ั‹ัˆ ??ัั€ ัŠั€ัŠ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ััŽั„ัŽััั”? ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ั‘ ?ะ„ะŽัŽัŒ ั‚ ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ัŽััŽั‹ัŽั†ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ั—ัŽัŒัŽั”ั‡ัˆัŽั‘ (ะ„ัŽั‰ ั†ั… ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ) ั‘ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ััŽ ?ัˆัŠั…ั‰ั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ั€ ั‚ั…ะ?. ??ั„ั€??ัˆัŒัˆั‘  ั‘ะั…ั„ัˆ ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ััˆัŠัŽั‚ ?ะะ„ัŽั„ัŽัŠั‘ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽัƒัŽ ั”ัžั…ััˆ  ััŽั‘ั‹ั… ั‘ัŽััŽะั€ ั‚ ?ัˆัŠั…ั… ั?ั‹ัˆ ?ััŽั‹ั‹ัˆัั€ะัˆั‰ ัˆ ?ั€ะัŠั…ั‹ั‹. ?ัั€ ััŽั„ะ„ั‚ั…ะั†ั„ั€ั‹ัˆ ัะัˆัะŽัˆั ั…ั„ัˆััŽััŽั†ัˆ  ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั”? ัะัˆะัŽั„ั” ั‚ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั…, ััŽ ัŽะ„ะัˆะŽั€ั‹ัˆ ?ัƒัŽ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆััั”? ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั”? ัะัˆะัŽั„ั”, ั„ัŽัŠั€ั‡?ั‚ั€ , ัžะ„ัŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั€  ั‚ัŽั‹  ั‘ั„ั…ั‹ั€ั‹ั€ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั”? ัะัˆะัŽั„ั” ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ ัั€ั‘ั‘ัˆั‚ั?ัŒ, ัั…ั‡ั„ั… ะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ั?ัŒ ัŽะั”ั„ัˆั…ัŒ. ?ะ„ัˆ ะั€ั‡ั?ั… ัะัŽัั‹ั…ัŒ? ัะัˆั‚ั…ั‹ัˆ ัŠ ั‘ัŽั‡?ั‚ั” ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัŽััŽะั€ ั‚ 381 ัƒ. ั‚ ?ัŽัั‘ะ„ั€ัะ„ัˆััŽััŽั‹ั…. ?ะ„ัŽะ„ ั‘ัŽััŽะ ััŽั„ะ„ั‚ั…ะั„ัˆั‹ ?ัˆัŠั…ั‰ั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ ั‚ั…ะ?, ั‘ั„ั…ั‹ั€ั‚ ััŽั‹ั…ั…  ั‘ั?ัŒ ั…ัƒัŽ ั‡ัั€ัžั…ััˆั…, ัˆ ัะัŽั‚ัŽั‡ัƒั‹ั€ั‘ัˆั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ั‚ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั… ัะัˆั‘ั”ะ„ั‘ะ„ั‚ั”?ะ„ ั„ั‚ั… ั„ั…ั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ั?ั— ัะัˆะัŽั„?.

?ั…ั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒ

?ัŽั‘ั‹ั… ั‘ัŽััŽะั€ ั‚ ?ัŽัั‘ะ„ั€ัะ„ัˆััŽััŽั‹ั… ั‚ััˆัŒั€ััˆั… ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ ั?ั‹ัŽ ัั€ัะั€ั‚ั‹ั…ััŽ ัŠ ะ„ั€ัŠ ัั€ั‡?ั‚ั€ั…ัŒัŽัŒั” ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ัŽัƒัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽัŒั” ั€ั‘ัั…ัŠะ„ั” ัะัŽัั‹ั…ัŒ? ั‚ ัะัˆะัŽั„ั… ัˆ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€. ??ั‹ัˆ ั‘ั„ั…ั‹ั€ั? ััŽั?ะ„ัŠัˆ - ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹ัˆะ„โ„– ัะัˆะัŽั„ั” ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัั?ั— ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั— ยคั‹ั…ัŒั…ัะ„ัŽั‚ ั‚ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั… ัˆ ัˆั‡ั‹ัŽั†ัˆะ„โ„– ั‚ั‡ั€ัˆัŒัŽัŽะ„ััŽยฐั…ััˆั… ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ััˆัŒัˆ. ?ั€ัŠ ัŒัŽัƒั”ะ„ ั„ั‚ั… ั‹ัˆัžั?ั— ัะัˆะัŽั„? ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ะ„โ„– ั‚ัŒั…ั‘ะ„ั… ั‚ ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ?

?ะ„ั€ ะ‡ั€ั‡ั€ ััŽะโ„–ั? ั‘ัŠัŽัะŽั…ัะ„ะัˆะัŽั‚ั€ั‹ั€ั‘โ„– ั‚ ั„ั‚ั”ั— ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ัŽััŽั‹ัŽั†ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ยฐัŠัŽั‹ั€ั— ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ัˆ ัŽั„ัั€ ั‚ ?ั‹ั…ัŠั‘ั€ัั„ะัˆัˆ ั€ ั‚ะ„ัŽะั€  ั‚ ?ัะ„ัˆัŽั—ัˆัˆ ?ัˆะัˆั‰ั‘ัŠัŽั‰. ?ะ„ัˆ ัŽัั€ ััŽัƒัŽั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ั‘ัŠัˆั… ัั€ัะั€ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆ  ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ัˆ ัะัˆั‡ัั€ั‚ั€ั‹ัˆ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัััŽั… ั…ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ั‚ ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ - ั‚ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั… ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั…, ััŽ ?ั‹ั…ัŠั‘ั€ัั„ะัˆั‰ั‘ัŠั€  ยฐัŠัŽั‹ั€ ััŽั„ัž?ะัŠัˆั‚ั€ั‹ั€ ั…ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ั„ั‚ั”ั— ัะัˆะัŽั„ ัˆ ัั€ั‘ะ„ั€ัˆั‚ั€ั‹ั€ ัั€ ั‚ั€ั†ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰, ั‚ ะ„ัŽ ั‚ะั…ัŒ  ัŠั€ัŠ ?ัะ„ัˆัŽั—ัˆั‰ั‘ัŠั€  ยฐัŠัŽั‹ั€ ััŽั„ัž?ะัŠัˆั‚ั€ั‹ั€ ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžัˆั… ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ั„ั‚ั”ัŒ  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ัŒัˆ ัˆ ัั€ั‘ะ„ั€ัˆั‚ั€ั‹ั€ ัั€ ั‚ั€ั†ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั€ั‘ัั…ัŠะ„ั€. ?ะ„ัŽะัŽัััˆัŠัˆ ?ัะ„ัˆัŽั—ัˆั‰ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ยฐัŠัŽั‹? ัะัˆั„ั…ะั†ัˆั‚ั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ั€, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั€  ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั€  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ ั‡ั€ยฐั‹ัˆ ั‚ ัŽะ„ััŽยฐั…ััˆ  ััŽั‘ะ„ัŽ ัััŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัŽั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ััˆ  ัˆ ั‘ัŽะ„ะั”ั„ััˆัžั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ัั…ั‡ ั„ั…ั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽัƒัŽ ั‘ั‹ัˆ ััˆ . ? ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ัŽััˆ ัŽะ„ั„ั…ั‹ ั‹ัˆ ั„ั‚ั… ัะัˆะัŽั„?, ั‡ั€ ั‚ั‹  , ัžะ„ัŽ ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ััˆัŒัˆ ัั… ั?ั‹ัŽ ััŽั„ัŽัััŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัŽ?ั‡ั€, ััŽ ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ัŠัŽ ััŽั‘ะ„ัŽ ัััŽั… ัŽั?ั…ััˆั…. ?ััˆ ัะัŽั‚ัŽั„ัˆั‹ัˆ ะั…ั‡ัŠัŽั… ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžัˆั… ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽัŒ ัŠั€ัŠ ??ััŽัŒ ?ัŽั†ัˆัˆัŒ ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽัŒ - ัŠั€ัŠ ั‘?ััŽัŒ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆัŒ, ัˆ ัะัˆั„ั€ั‚ั€ั‹ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„ั… ััŽั‹ั…ั…  ั‘ััŽั… ัˆ ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹?ัััŽั… ัะัˆั‡ัั€ััˆั…. ?ััˆ ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ ั‹ัˆ ั‘ั…ัั… ั…ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ั„ั‚ั”ั— ัะัˆะัŽั„ ัŠั€ัŠ ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ัˆั†ัˆัŒัŽั… ััŽั‘ะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ ั…ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ั‘ัŽัŽะ„ั‚ั…ะ„ั‘ะ„ั‚ั”??ัˆั— ัะัŽ ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆั‰ ั‚ัŽั‹ัˆ. ?ััˆ ัŽะ„ั‘ะ„ั€ัˆั‚ั€ั‹ัˆ ะั…ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ัˆ ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€, ััŽ ััŽั„ั‚ั…ะัƒั€ั‹ัˆ ัŽัั€ั‘ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ั…ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ. ?ะ„ัŽ ั?ั‹ ัั… ััŽั‹ั?ั‰, ัั…ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัั?ั‰, ัั…ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹?ัั?ั‰ ัŒั…ั—ั€ััˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ั‘ัŽ?ั‡, ั‚ ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽัŒ ั„ั‚ั… ัะัˆะัŽั„? ัั… ั?ั‹ัˆ ั‚ัŽัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัั” ั‘ัŽั…ั„ัˆัั…ั? ั‚ ั…ั„ัˆััŽั‰, ั‘ัŽั‡ัั€??ั…ั‰ ั‘ั…ั  ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ. ?ะ„ัŽะัŽัััˆัŠัˆ ?ั‹ั…ัŠั‘ั€ัั„ะัˆั‰ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ยฐัŠัŽั‹?, - ั‘ ั„ะั”ัƒัŽั‰ ั‘ะ„ัŽะัŽั?, ัŽั‘ัŽั‡ัั€ั‚ั€ั‹ัˆ ัžั”ั„ั…ั‘ััŽั… ัˆ ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัััŽั… ั‘ั‹ัˆ ััˆั… ั„ั‚ั”ั— ัะัˆะัŽั„; ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั€  ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ะั€ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽะัˆั‹ั€ั‘โ„– ั‚ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัˆ ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ั€ ััŽั„ัžัˆั?ัััŽั‰ ััŽ ัŽะ„ััŽยฐั…ััˆ? ัŠ ัั…ั‰. ?ั€ัŠัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ, ?ัŽัƒ ั‚ัŽยฐ?ั‹ ั‚ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั”? ัะัˆะัŽั„ั” ัˆ ััŽั‘ะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัŽ?ั‡ั€ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั…ั‘ะ„ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ั‘ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆัŒ, ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ัŽ ั‚ัŽั‡ัŒัŽั†ั?ัŒ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั” ัะัˆั‚ั…ั‘ะ„ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ัŽัะั€ะ„ััŽ ัŠ ?ัŽัƒั”. ?ะ„ัŽั‹ัŠััŽั‚ั…ััˆ  ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ยคะ„ัˆัŒัˆ ั„ั‚ั”ัŒ  ยฐัŠัŽั‹ั€ัŒัˆ ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ัˆ ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ัˆัƒั‹ัˆ ั‘ั‚ัŽั…ัƒัŽ ั‚?ั‘ยฐั…ัƒัŽ ัั€ัŠั€ั‹ั€ ั‚ ?ั…ั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัŽัŒ ั‘ััŽะั… ั‚ ัั€ัžั€ั‹ั… V ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ . ?ั…ั‘ะ„ัŽะ ัˆั‡ ?ัะ„ัˆัŽั—ัˆัˆ ัะัˆั‡ัั€ั‚ั€ั‹ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆััั”? ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั”? ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั”? ัะัˆะัŽั„ั”, ััŽ ัŽะ„ะัˆะŽั€ั‹ ัˆั— ั‘ัŽ?ั‡ ั‚ ั…ั„ัˆััŽั‰, ั‘ัŽั‡ัั€??ั…ั‰ ั‘ั…ั  ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ. ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘, ั‘ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ััŽ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ั” ัั…ั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆั€ั ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ ั‹ ั‘ัŽััŽั‰ ั„ั‚ั… ะั…ั€ั‹โ„–ั?ั— ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ, ัั€ั‘ั‹ั€ั†ั„ั€??ัˆั—ั‘  ัŒัŽะั€ั‹โ„–ั?ัŒ ัˆ ััŽั‹ั?ัŒ ั‘ัŽัžั”ั‚ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆ  ั‘ัŽ?ั‡ัŽัŒ, ััŽ ัั… ัะัŽัˆั‡ั‚ัŽั„ ?ัˆั— ััˆัŠั€ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ะั…ยฐัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽัƒัŽ ั‚ัŽั‡ั„ั…ั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆ  ั„ะั”ัƒ ัั€ ั„ะั”ัƒั€. ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ั‚ ั„ั€ัััŽัŒ ั‘ั‹ั”ัžั€ั… ัั… ั?ั‹ัŽ ั”ััˆั†ั…ััŽ; ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠั€  ัะัˆะัŽั„ั€ ัั… ั?ั‹ั€ ั‚ัŽั‡ั‚?ยฐั…ัั€. ? ะ„ั€ัŠัŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ั?ั‹ ?ัŽัƒ ัˆ ั?ั‹ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠ; ััŽ ั‚ ัั…ั‰ ัั… ั?ั‹ัŽ ?ัŽัƒัŽัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠั€.

? 431 ัƒัŽั„ั” ั‚ ?ะ‡ั…ั‘ั… ั?ั‹ ั‘ัŽั‡ั„ั€ั ?ะั…ะ„ัˆั‰ ?ัŠั”ัŒั…ััˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ?ั…ะัŠัŽั‚ั?ั‰ ?ัŽััŽะ ั‘ ะŽั…ั‹โ„–? - ั”ะั…ัƒั”ั‹ัˆะัŽั‚ั€ะ„โ„– ยคะ„ัŽะ„ ั‘ััŽะ ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ?ัะ„ัˆัŽั—ัˆั‰ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัˆ ?ั‹ั…ัŠั‘ั€ัั„ะัˆั‰ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ยฐัŠัŽั‹ั€ัŒัˆ ัŒ?ยฐั‹ั…ััˆ . ?ัŽััŽะ ัŽั‘ั”ั„ัˆั‹ ?ั…ั‘ะ„ัŽะั€ ัˆ ั…ัƒัŽ ั”ัžั…ััˆั…, ััŽ ัั… ััŽั‘ัžัˆะ„ั€ั‹ ัั…ัŽัั—ัŽั„ัˆัŒ?ัŒ ั‚?ั„ั‚ัˆัั”ะ„โ„– ััŽั‚?ั‰ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ ั‚ั…ะ? ั‚ัŒั…ั‘ะ„ัŽ ?ัˆัŠั…ั‰ั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ัˆัŒั‚ัŽั‹ั€. ?ั€ ยคะ„ัŽัŒ ั‘ัŽััŽะั… ัั… ั?ั‹ัŽ ัžะ„ัŽ-ั‹ัˆััŽ ะั…ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽ ั”ะั…ัƒั”ั‹ัˆะัŽั‚ั€ััŽ ัˆั‹ัˆ ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ัˆัƒัั”ะ„ัŽ; ัˆั‘ัŠั‹?ัžั€  ั…?? ััŽั‹ั…ั… ั”ั‚ั…ั‹ัˆัžัˆั‚ยฐัˆั‰ั‘  ะั€ั‡ั‹ั€ั„, ัˆ ััŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ั”??ั€  ััŽะโ„–ัั€ ัะัˆั ั‹ั€ ะ„ั€ัŠัˆั… ะั€ั‡ัŒั…ะ?, ัžะ„ัŽ ั‚ั‘ั… ั„ะั”ัƒัˆั… ั„ัŽัŠะ„ะัˆัั€ั‹โ„–ั?ั… ัะัŽัั‹ั…ัŒ? ั?ั‹ัˆ ัŽะ„ั‹ัŽั†ั…ั?.