ะงะธั‚ะฐะนั‚ะต ะบะฝะธะณะธ ะพะฝะปะฐะนะฝ ะฝะฐ Bookidrom.ru! ะ‘ะตัะฟะปะฐั‚ะฝั‹ะต ะบะฝะธะณะธ ะฒ ะพะดะฝะพะผ ะบะปะธะบะต

ะงะธั‚ะฐั‚ัŒ ะพะฝะปะฐะนะฝ ยซะšะพะผะผะตะฝั‚ะฐั€ะธะน ะะดะฒะตะฝั‚ะธัั‚ะพะฒ ะกะตะดัŒะผะพะณะพ ะ”ะฝั ะฝะฐ ะ•ะฒะฐะฝะณะตะปะธะต ะพั‚ ะ˜ะพะฐะฝะฝะฐยป. ะกั‚ั€ะฐะฝะธั†ะฐ 13

ะะฒั‚ะพั€ ะฝะตะธะทะฒะตัั‚ะตะฝ ะะฒั‚ะพั€

?ัŽ ััŽ ัะัŽยฐั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆัˆ ั€ััŽั‘ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ััŽัŠัŽั‹ั…ััˆ  (ั‘ัŒ. ?ะ„ัŠ. 2:4, ั‘ะ. ?ั‘. ?ั€ั‚. 24:31) ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆั… ัŽ ั†ัˆั‚ัŽัŒ ?ัŽั‘ััŽั„ั… ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ัŽ ะ„ั”ั‘ัŠัั…ะ„โ„–, ัˆ ัั…ะั‚ัŽัั€ัžั€ั‹โ„–ัั€  ัžัˆั‘ะ„ัŽะ„ั€ ัˆ ััŽั‘ั‚ ?ั…ััˆั… ั”ัŒั…ัโ„–ยฐัˆั‹ัˆั‘โ„–, ั‹?ั„ัˆ ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ัˆ ัŽัะั€?ั€ะ„โ„– ััŽั‹โ„–ยฐั… ั‚ััˆัŒั€ััˆ  ัั… ัะั€ัŠะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆัŒ ะั…ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽั‘ะ„ ัŒ ?ั‚ั€ััƒั…ั‹ัˆ , ั€ ั…ัƒัŽ ัˆัะ„ะัˆัƒั”??ัˆัŒ, ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ ?ัˆัŒ ั‚ ะ„ั”ััˆัŠ ะ„ั…ัŽะั…ะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆัŒ ั€ั‘ัั…ัŠะ„ั€ัŒ, ััˆะ„ั€  ัˆั‹ั‹?ั‡ัˆ?, ัžะ„ัŽ ััŽั‘ะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ ัˆั‘ั‘ั‹ั…ั„ัŽั‚ั€ััˆ  ั‡ั€ัั”ะ„ั€ัั?ั— ะ‡ั€ัŠะ„ัŽะัŽั‚ ะ‡ัˆั‹ัŽั‘ัŽะ‡ัˆัˆ, ัŽััˆ, ั‚ัŽั‡ัŒัŽั†ััŽ, ั‘ัŒัŽัƒั”ะ„ ััŽั‡ัั€ะ„โ„– ?ัŽัƒั€ (ั‘ัŒ. ?ัŽั‚ั€ 11:7, ?ัˆัŒ. 11:33). ?ะั…ั„ัˆ ััŽั„ั ั‚ยฐัˆั—ั‘  ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžั?ั— ั…ะั…ั‘ั…ั‰, ัะัˆัžัˆััˆั‚ยฐัˆั— ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ัŠัŽ ั‘ัŠัŽะััˆ ั„ั‹  ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ, ััˆ ัŽั„ัั€ ัั… ั?ั‹ั€ ััŽั‹ั…ั… ั‘ั…ะโ„–?ั‡ััŽั‰, ัŠั€ัŠ ะ„ั…, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ัˆัŒั…ั‹ัˆ ัŽะ„ััŽยฐั…ััˆั… ัŠ ัะัˆะัŽั„ั… ัˆ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€. ?ััŽะ ัˆ ััŽะโ„–ัั€, ะั€ั‡ั‚ั…ะัั”ั‚ยฐัˆั…ั‘  ั‚ัŽัŠะั”ัƒ ยคะ„ัŽั‰ ัะัŽัั‹ั…ัŒ?, ััŽะ„ะ ั‘ั€ั‹ัˆ ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚โ„– ัั… ัะัŽะ„ ั†ั…ััˆัˆ ัŒััŽัƒัˆั— ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆั‰ ัˆ ัŽั‡ัั€ัŒั…ััŽั‚ั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ัั…ัะั…ะ?ั‚ััŽั‰ ะŽั…ัโ„–? ั…ะั…ั‘ั…ั‰, ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚ั?ั— ั‘ัŽััŽะัŽั‚ ัˆ ะั€ั‘ัŠัŽั‹ัŽั‚.

?ั‹  ั‚ั‘ั…ั—, ัั…  ั‚ั‹ ??ัˆั—ั‘  ัˆั‘ั‘ั‹ั…ั„ัŽั‚ั€ะ„ั…ั‹ ัŒัˆ ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚ััŽั‰ ัˆั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆัˆ, ััŽั„ะัŽัััŽั… ัˆั‡ั”ัžั…ััˆั… ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั‚ั…ั‹ัˆัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ััŽะั€ ัŒัŽั†ั…ะ„ ั?ะ„โ„– ั‹ัˆยฐั…ััŽ ัˆัะ„ั…ะั…ั‘ั€ ัˆ ัะั€ัŠะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ะŽั…ัััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ. ?ัŽ ั‘ั…ัƒัŽั„ั  ัั… ัŒั…ัั…ั… ัžั…ัŒ ั‚ ั€ััŽั‘ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ั‘ัŠัˆั… ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ัั€ ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹?ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ัˆ ั”ั‚ั…ะั…ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ั‚ ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั‚ั…ะั… ัŠัŽัะŽั…ัะ„ะัˆะั”ั…ะ„ั‘  ั‚ ัˆั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽัŒ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั… ?ัŽั‚ัŽัƒัŽ ?ั€ั‚ั…ะ„ั€. ?ั€ัŠั†ั… ั‚ ัŽั„ััŽัŒ ัˆั‹ัˆ ั„ะั”ัƒัŽัŒ ั‚ัˆั„ั…, ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžั?ั… ั„ะั…ั‚ััˆั… ั…ะั…ั‘ัˆ ัˆั‹ัˆ ัะัŽั„ัŽั‹ั†ั€?ะ„ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ะ„โ„–, ัˆั‹ัˆ ัะัŽ ั‚ั‹ ?ะ„ั‘  ั‘ััŽั‚ั€. ?ั‡ ัŠะั€ะ„ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ัŽััŽั‡ะั…ััˆ  ัŠั”ะั‘ั€ ยคะ„ัŽั‰ ั‚ั…ั‹ัˆัŠัŽั‰ ััŽะโ„–ั? ั‘ ั‘ั€ัŒ?ั— ะั€ัััˆั— ั‚ะั…ัŒ?ั, ั‘ัŽั‚ะั…ัŒั…ัั?ั… ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั… ัŒัŽัƒั”ะ„ ััŽั‹ั”ัžัˆะ„โ„– ั—ัŽะัŽยฐัˆั‰ ั”ะัŽัŠ, ัˆ ั?ะ„โ„– ัั„ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ั?ัŒัˆ ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ ััŽั„ัŽัั?ั— ั‡ั€ัั‹ั”ั†ั„ั…ััˆั‰, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ั”ั‚ั‹ั…ัŠั‹ัˆ ัˆั— ััŽั‘ั‚ ??ัั?ั— ัะั€ะ„โ„–ั…ั‚ ั‚ ัะัŽยฐั‹?ั… ั‚ั…ัŠั€ (ั‘ัŒ. ?ั. 8:32, 1 ?ั. 4:1).

?ั‚ั€ ัƒั‹ั€ั‚ั?ั— ัั€ัะั€ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆ  ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั„ั‹ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽัƒัŽ ั‘ััŽะั€ ัˆั‡ั‚ั…ั‘ะ„ั? ัŠั€ัŠ ะ„ะัˆััˆะ„ั€ะััŽั… ัˆ ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ัŽัƒัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั…. ?ั…ะั‚?ั‰ ั€ั‘ัั…ัŠะ„ ัˆัŒั…ั‹ ั„ั…ั‹ัŽ ั‘ ััŽั‹ัŽั†ั…ััˆั…ัŒ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ ัŠั€ัŠ ?ัŽัƒั€, ั€ ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽั‰ - ั‘ ั‚ัŽัั‹ัŽ?ั…ััˆั…ัŒ, ั‚ั‡ั€ัˆัŒัŽัŽะ„ััŽยฐั…ััˆั…ัŒ ัŒั…ั†ั„ั” ?ัƒัŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‰ ัˆ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„ัŽั‰. ?ัŽะโ„–ัั€ ะ„ะัˆััˆะ„ั€ะัˆั…ั‚, ัŽะ„ั‘ะ„ั€ัˆั‚ั€??ัˆั— ั„ัŽัƒัŒั€ะ„ ะ„ะัŽัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€, ัŠัŽัะŽั…ัะ„ะัˆะัŽั‚ั€ั‹ั‘  ั‚ ั‘ะั€ั†ั…ััˆัˆ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ ั‘ ?ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆั‡ัŒัŽัŒ, ?ัŽัั€ะั—ัˆั‡ัŒัŽัŒ ัˆ ?ะัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒัŽัŒ ั‘ ัั…ะั‚ัŽัƒัŽ ััŽ ัžั…ะ„ั‚?ะะ„ัŽั… ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆั…; ัˆ ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ัŽัƒัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ั‘ััŽะ ั‚ ั…ัƒัŽ ััˆะ„ั‚ั€ั— ั‘ ?ั…ั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒัŽัŒ, ?ัŽััŽะ‡ัˆั‡ัˆะ„ัˆั‡ัŒัŽัŒ ัˆ ?ัŽััŽะ‡ั…ั‹ัˆะ„ัˆั‡ัŒัŽัŒ ั‘ V ััŽ VII ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆั….

?ััŽั‘ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ั‘ัŠั€  ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚โ„–. ?ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ ัˆั‹ัˆ ั‚ั…ะั€ ั€ััŽั‘ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ ัŽะ„ััŽั‘ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€ ั—ัŽะัŽยฐัŽ ััŽั„?ะ„ัŽั†ั…ัั€ ั‚ ั”ะ„ั‚ั…ะั†ั„ั…ััˆัˆ ?ั…ะ„ะั€, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ ั…ั‘ะ„โ„– "?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ??ั ?ัŽัƒั€ ?ัˆั‚ัŽัƒัŽ" (?ะ‡. 16:16), ัˆ ั‚ ัะัŽั‘ะ„ัŽัŒ ัˆั‡ั‹ัŽั†ั…ััˆัˆ ั‚ั…ะ?, ัŠั€ัŠ ัŽััŽ ัะัˆั‚ั…ั„ั…ััŽ ั€ั. ?ั€ั‚ั‹ัŽัŒ: "?ัˆัŠะ„ัŽ ัั… ัŒัŽั†ั…ะ„ ัั€ั‡ั‚ั€ะ„โ„– ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€ ?ัŽั‘ััŽั„ัŽัŒ, ัŠั€ัŠ ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ัŠัŽ ?ั”ั—ัŽัŒ ?ั‚ ะ„?ัŒ". ?ั„ั…ั‘โ„– ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ัŽ ?ัŽั‘ััŽั„โ„– - ั‚ ัƒะ. ััŽั„ั‹ัˆัััˆัŠั… "?ั”ะัˆัŽั‘" ะั€ั‚ััŽั‡ัั€ัžั…ั ั…ั‚ะั…ั‰ั‘ัŠัŽัŒั” ?ั…ัƒัŽั‚ั… (1 ?ัŽะ. 12:3). ?ั…ะั‚?ั… ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั… ั‚ั…ะัˆั‹ัˆ, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘  ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ั‘  ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ั‚ ั‘ั€ัŒัŽัŒ ั‚?ั‘ัŽัŠัŽัŒ ั‘ัŒ?ั‘ั‹ั… ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ั€, ัˆ ั‘ั„ั…ั‹ั€ั‹ัˆ ยคะ„ัŽะ„ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ ัŠะั€ั…ั”ัƒัŽั‹โ„–ั?ัŒ ัŠั€ัŒัั…ัŒ ั‘ั‚ัŽั…ั‰ ั‚ั…ะ? (ั‘ัŒ. ัั€ ?ะ‡. 16:18). "?ั‹ัŽะ„โ„– ัˆ ัŠะัŽั‚โ„–" ัั… ัŒัŽัƒั‹ัˆ ัŽะ„ัŠะ?ะ„โ„– ัˆั‹ัˆ ัŽัยท ั‘ััˆะ„โ„– ยคะ„ั” ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัั”; ั…? ัั…ัŽัั—ัŽั„ัˆัŒัŽ ัะัˆั ะ„โ„– ั‚ั…ะัŽั‰ (ั‘ัŒ. ?ะ‡. 16:17). ?ะ„ั€ ัั…ั‡ัŽัƒัŽั‚ัŽะัŽัžัั€  ั”ั‚ั…ะั…ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ัั…ะั‚ัŽั?ะ„ััŽั‰ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ ัŽะ„ััŽั‘ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ะ„ะัŽั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ัˆ ััŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽ-ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€, ั?ั‹ั€ ัŽั‘ััŽั‚ั€ัั€ ัั€  ั‘ั?ั—, ัŽัะั…ั„ั…ั‹?ัั?ั— ั”ัžั…ััˆ ั— ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€ ัˆ ั€ััŽั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ัŽั‚. ?ั„ัั€ัŠัŽ, ั‚ั‘ัŠัŽะั… ััŽั‘ั‹ั… ั‚ัŽั‡ัั…ั‘ั…ััˆ  ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ ัั€ ัั…ััŽ "ั‹?ะ„?ั… ั‚ัŽั‹ัŠัˆ" ัั€ัžั€ั‹ัˆ ัั€ัั€ั„ั€ะ„โ„– ัั€ ั‘ะ„ั€ั„ัŽ ัˆ ั‚ัั”ะ„ะัˆ ั‘ั€ัŒัŽั‰ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ ั‚ัŽั‘ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ัˆ ั‹?ั„ัˆ "ัƒัŽั‚ัŽะ ?ัˆั… ัะั…ั‚ะั€ะ„ััŽ", ั„ั€ั? ั”ั‚ั‹ั…ัžโ„– ั”ัžั…ััˆัŠัŽั‚ ั‡ั€ ั‘ัŽััŽ? (?ั… ััˆ  20:29,30).

?ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆั‡ัŒ ัˆ ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆะŽัˆั‡ัŒ. ?ั…ะั‚ัŽั… ั‡ั€ัั‹ั”ั†ั„ั…ััˆั…, ัŠั€ั‘ั€??ั…ั…ั‘  ัะัˆะัŽั„? ัˆ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ - ัŽั?ัžััŽ ัŽะ„ััŽั‘ัˆะ„ั‘  ัŠ ?ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆั‡ัŒั”. ?ะ„ัŽ ัั€ั‡ั‚ั€ััˆั… ัะัŽัˆั‘ั—ัŽั„ัˆะ„ ัŽะ„ ัƒะ. ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ั€, ัŽััŽั‡ัั€ัžั€??ั…ัƒัŽ "ััŽัŠั€ั‡ั€ะ„โ„–ั‘ ", "ัŠั€ั‡ั€ะ„โ„–ั‘ ". ?ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆั‡ัŒ ัะัˆััˆัŒั€ั‹ ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžั?ั… ะ‡ัŽะัŒ?, ััŽ ั…ัƒัŽ ัŽั‘ััŽั‚ัั€  ัˆั„ั…  ั‡ั€ัŠั‹?ัžั€ั‹ั€ั‘โ„– ั‚ ะ„ัŽัŒ, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ัŠัŽ ัŠั€ั‡ั€ั‹ัŽั‘โ„– ัˆัŒั…ั‹ ะ„ั…ั‹ัŽ, ััŽ ั?ั‹ ัะัˆั‡ะั€ัŠัŽัŒ, ัˆ ัั… ั?ั‹ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠัŽัŒ ั‚ัŽัŽั?ั…. ?ั‹ัŽั‚ัŽ ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ัŽ ัั‹ัŽะ„โ„–?, ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ัŠัŽ ั‚ ั‚ัˆั„ั… ัะัˆั‡ะั€ัŠั€. ?ะ„ัŽ ั‡ั€ัั‹ั”ั†ั„ั…ััˆั… ั‚ัŽั‡ััˆัŠั‹ัŽ ั‚ ั€ััŽั‘ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ั‘ัŠัˆั… ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ัั€ ัˆ ัะัŽั„ัŽั‹ั†ั€ั‹ัŽ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽั‚ั€ะ„โ„– ั„ั€ั†ั… ั„ัŽ ัŠัŽัะŽั€ ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ . ?ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆั‡ัŒ ั?ั‹ ั—ั€ะั€ัŠะ„ั…ะััŽั‰ ัั…ัŽะ„ยทั…ัŒั‹ั…ัŒัŽั‰ ัžั…ะะ„ัŽั‰ ะ„ั€ัŠัˆั— ัƒะั”ัั, ัŠั€ัŠ ?ััˆัŽััˆะ„? ัˆ ?ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัŠัˆ. ?ั…ะั‚?ั… ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ ั‹ัˆ ั‘ัŽััŽั‰ ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ั ัˆั‡ ัˆั”ั„ั…ั…ั‚, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ั‘ะ„ะัŽัƒัŽ ัะัˆั„ั…ะั†ัˆั‚ั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ัŽัะ ั„ัŽั‚ ัˆ ัŽั?ัžั€ั…ั‚ ?ั”ั„ั€ัˆั‡ัŒั€. ?ัŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ััˆั… ัะั…ัˆัŒั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽ ั?ั‹ัˆ ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั€ัŒัˆ ัˆั‡  ั‡?ัžััˆัŠัŽั‚. ?ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆะŽัˆั‡ัŒ ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ ั‹ ั‘ัŽััŽั‰ ัั…ัŒััŽัƒัŽ ััŽั‹ั…ั… ัžั…ัŒ ั‘ัŒั…ั‘โ„– ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžั?ั—  ั‡?ัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั— ะ‡ัˆั‹ัŽั‘ัŽะ‡ั‘ัŠัˆั— ัˆั„ั…ั‰, ัŒั€ั‘ัŠัˆะัŽั‚ั€ั‚ยฐัˆั—ั‘  ััŽั„ ั‚ัˆั„ัŽัŒ ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ะ„ั…ะัŒัˆััŽั‹ัŽัƒัˆัˆ.

?ั€ัั   ัˆ ั‚ัŽั‡ัŒัŽั†ััŽ ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ัŽั‚ั…ะัั€  ะ„ะั€ั„ัˆะŽัˆ  ัŽะ„ัŽั†ั„ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั‹ ั…ะ„ ?ัˆัŒัŽัั€ ั‚ัŽั‹ั—ั‚ั€ (ั‘ัŒ. ?ั… ััˆ  8:9-24) ัŠั€ัŠ ัั…ะั‚ัŽัƒัŽ ั‡ั€?ัˆะ„ััˆัŠั€ ั‡ั€ัั‹ั”ั†ั„ั…ััˆ , ัŠั€ั‘ั€??ั…ัƒัŽั‘  ัะัˆะัŽั„? ัˆ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€, ัˆ ัŠั€ัŠ ัั…ะั‚ัŽัƒัŽ ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัŠั€. ?ั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‹โ„–ัŠัŽ ั‹ั…ะ„ ั‘ัั”ั‘ะ„  ั‚ ?ั‹ั…ัŠั‘ั€ัั„ะัˆัˆ ั‚ัŽั‘ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ััˆั ััŽ ัˆัŒั…ััˆ ?ั…ะัˆัะ‡, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ัั…ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ัะัˆัžัˆั‘ั‹ ั‹ัˆ ัŠ ยคััˆัŽััˆะ„ั€ัŒ, ั€ ั„ะั”ัƒัˆั… - ัŠ ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัŠั€ัŒ. ?ั ัŽะ„ะัˆะŽั€ั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ัะัˆั—ัŽั„ัˆั‹, ั”ะ„ั‚ั…ะั†ั„ั€ , ัžะ„ัŽ ?ัƒัŽ ัะั…ั„ััŽั‹ั€ัƒั€ั…ัŒัŽั… ั‚ัŽัั‹ัŽ?ั…ััˆั… ั?ั‹ัŽ ัŠั€ั†ั”?ัˆัŒั‘ , ััŽ ัั… ะั…ั€ั‹โ„–ั?ัŒ. ?ััˆัŽััˆะ„? ัั… ั?ั‹ัˆ ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัŠั€ัŒัˆ, ััŽ ัะัˆั„ั…ะั†ัˆั‚ั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ะ„ั€ัŠัˆั— ั†ั… ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ัŽั‚ ัŽะ„ััŽั‘ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ัะัˆะัŽั„? ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€. ?ััˆ ะั€ั‘ั‘ัŒั€ะ„ะัˆั‚ั€ั‹ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ ั‹ัˆยฐโ„– ัŠั€ัŠ ัั”ัŠั‚ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽัƒัŽ ั‘?ัั€ ?ัŽั‘ัˆะ‡ั€, ััŽ ัˆั‡ัะั€ัััŽัƒัŽ ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ, ัŠั€ัŠ ?ั…ั‘ั‘ัˆ?, ััŽั‘ัŠัŽั‹โ„–ัŠั” ?ั ั‚?ั„ั…ั‹ ั‹ั‘  ัั‹ั€ัƒัŽัžั…ั‘ะ„ัˆั…ัŒ ัˆ ั‘ัŽัั‹?ั„ั…ััˆั…ัŒ ั‡ั€ัŠัŽัั€ ัˆ ั?ั‹ ัะัˆั ะ„ ัŠั€ัŠ ??ั ?ัŽั†ัˆั‰ ัะัˆ ?ั‚ัŽ?ัŒ ัŠะั…?ั…ััˆัˆ. ?ั„ััŽ ัˆั‡ ัŽะ„ั‚ั…ะ„ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆั… ยคััˆัŽััˆะ„ัŽั‚ - ยคั‹โ„–ัŠั…ั‡ั€ัˆะ„?, ั”ัžัˆั‹ัˆ, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ัŽั‘ ั?ั‹ ัั”ัŠั‚ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽ "ะัŽั†ั„?ั ัŽะ„ ?ัŽัƒั€" ั‚ ัะัŽยฐั‹?ั— ั‚ั…ัŠั€ั— ัˆ ั?ั‹, ะ„ั€ัŠัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ, ััŽั„ัžัˆั?ั ?ัŒั”.

? ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ัŽััŽั‹ัŽั†ััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ยคััˆัŽััˆะ„ั€ัŒ, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ะั€ั‘ั‘ัŒั€ะ„ะัˆั‚ั€ั‹ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ ัŠั€ัŠ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽ ั‚?ั‘ยฐัˆั‰ ะ„ัˆั ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ, ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัŠัˆ, ั‚ัŽัŽั?ั… ัƒัŽั‚ัŽะ , ัŽะ„ะัˆะŽั€ั‹ัˆ, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ั ั?ั‹ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั‹ัˆัžััŽั‘ะ„โ„–? ั‚ัŽัŽั?ั…. ?ััˆ ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ ั‹ัˆ ั‘ั…ัั… ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ ัŠั€ัŠ ัะัˆั‡ะั€ัŠั€ ัˆั‹ัˆ ยคัŽัั€, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั‰ ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ัััŽ ัŽัั‹ั€ั„ั€ั‹ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ัŽัŒ - ัŽั?ัŠััŽั‚ั…ัั?ัŒ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆัŒ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽัŒ. ?ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ััŽ ัˆั— ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ั”, ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ัั… ั?ั‹ั€ ัั€ ั‘ั€ัŒัŽัŒ ั„ั…ั‹ั… ั‚ัŽัั‹ัŽ??ัััŽั‰. ?ะ„ััŽั‘ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ัƒะัŽัŒั€ั„ััŽัƒัŽ ั‚ั‹ัˆ ััˆ  ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆะŽัˆั‡ัŒั€ ัั€ ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ัŠั”? ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚โ„–, ัˆั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆัŠ ?ั€ั”ะ„ัŽะั…ะ„ะ„ัˆ ััŽั„ัž?ะัŠัˆั‚ั€ั…ะ„ ั‚ั…ะัŽ ะ„ััŽั‘ะ„โ„–, ัžะ„ัŽ "ัั€ ัะัŽะ„ ั†ั…ััˆัˆ ัั…ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ััˆ, ััŽั‹โ„–ยฐัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ะ„ั…ั—, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ั‘ัžัˆะ„ั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั€ัŒัˆ, ะ„ั‚?ะั„ัŽ ัะัˆั„ั…ะั†ัˆั‚ั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ัŽั„ััŽั‰ ัˆั‹ัˆ ั„ะั”ัƒัŽั‰ ัˆั‡ ั…ัƒัŽ ัŒััŽัƒัˆั— ะ‡ัŽะัŒ" (?. ?. ?ั€ั”ะ„ัŽะั…ะ„ะ„ัˆ. ?ั‘ะ„ัŽะัˆ  ั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ัˆั€ัั‘ะ„ั‚ั€. ?ะ„ะ. 123). ?ัŽั‡ััˆัŠัั”ั‚ ััŽั‘ะ„ั…ัั…ัััŽ ั‚ ั€ััŽั‘ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ั‘ัŠัˆั… ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ัั€, ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆะŽัˆั‡ัŒ ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ัˆัƒ ั‚ั…ะยฐัˆั? ั‘ั‚ัŽั…ัƒัŽ ั‚ั‹ัˆ ััˆ  ัั€ ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚โ„– ั‚ ัั…ะัˆัŽั„ ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ . ?ัŽั‡ัั€ั‚ั€  ั‘ั…ะโ„–?ั‡ัั”? ั”ัƒะัŽั‡ั” ั‚ ั‹ัˆะŽั… ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆะŽัˆั‡ัŒั€, ะŽั…ะัŠัŽั‚โ„– ัƒั…ะัŽัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆัŒ ัŽัะั€ั‡ัŽัŒ ั‘ะั€ั†ั€ั‹ั€ั‘โ„– ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ ัั…ัƒัŽ.

?ะัˆัั…ั‰, ััˆั‘ั€ั‚ยฐัˆั‰ ั‚ ััŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ัั…ั‰ ััŽั‹ัŽั‚ัˆัั… ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ , ัŽะ„ัŒั…ะ„ัˆั‹, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ัŽั€ัั ััˆั‘ั€ั‹ ั‘ั‚ัŽ? ?ั‚ั€ััƒั…ั‹ัˆั… ั‘ ัŽั‘ัŽััŽั‰ ะŽั…ั‹โ„–? - ัŽัะัŽั‚ั…ะัƒัั”ะ„โ„– ั„ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั… ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„? ?ั…ะัˆัะ‡ั€ (?ะัˆัั…ั‰ - ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ ั…ะั…ั‘ัˆ XI. I. 6; ั‘ัŒ. ?ั. 1:1 - 3:14, 20:30-31). ? ััŽั‘ั‹ั€ััˆ ั— ?ัŽั€ััั€ ั…?? ััŽั‹ั…ั… ะั…ั‡ัŠัŽ ั‚?ะั€ั†ั…ััŽ ัะั…ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ั…ะั…ั†ั…ััˆั… ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ ั„ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั…ะั…ั‘ัˆ, ั‡ั€?ัˆะ„ััˆัŠัŽั‚ ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽั‰ ัŽั ัั€ั‡?ั‚ั€ั…ะ„ "ั€ัะ„ัˆั—ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ัŒัˆ" (1 ?ั. 2:18-26, 4:1-3, 9:14, 2 ?ั. 7:10). ? ัั…ะัˆัŽั„ ั‘ั‚ัŽั…ัƒัŽ ัั…ะั‚ัŽัƒัŽ ะ„?ะั…ัŒััŽัƒัŽ ั‡ั€ัŠั‹?ัžั…ััˆ  ั‚ ?ัˆัŒั… (ัŽัŠัŽั‹ัŽ 60 ัƒ.) ?ั€ั‚ั…ั‹ ัะั…ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ั…ะั…ัƒั€ั‹ ั‚ั…ะั”??ัˆั— ั‚ ?ัŽั‹ัŽั‘ั‘ั€ั— ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ ั„ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽัƒัŽ ั‡ั€ัั‹ั”ั†ั„ั…ััˆ  (?ัŽั‹. 2:4, 8, 9, 18) ัˆ ัะัˆัั‹ัˆั‡ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ั‚ ะ„ัŽ ั†ั… ั‘ั€ัŒัŽั… ั‚ะั…ัŒ  ??ะ„ะ ัะัŽั‚ัŽั‡ัƒั‹ั€ั‘ัˆั‹ ั…?? ััŽั‹ั…ั… ั‘ัˆั‹โ„–ััŽั… ัะั…ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ั…ะั…ั†ั…ััˆั… (2 ?ั…ะ„. 2:1-3). ?ั”ั„ั€ 4 ั‘ั‘?ั‹ั€ั…ะ„ั‘  ัั€ ั„ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠั”? ั…ะั…ั‘โ„–. "?ัˆัŠัŽั‹ั€ัˆะ„?" ัˆั‡ ?ะ„ัŠะัŽั‚ั…ััˆ  2:6 ั?ั‹ัˆ ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัŠั€ัŒัˆ, ั—ัŽะ„  ัˆ ัั… ัŽั ั‡ั€ะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ั„ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆั‘ะ„ั€ัŒัˆ (?ะัˆัั…ั‰ ะ„ั€ัŒ ั†ั… ะ„. 1 426 ั‘ะ„ะ.).

? ัั…ะัˆัŽั„ ัั…ะั‚ัŽั‰ ััŽั‹ัŽั‚ัˆั? ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ  ั‚ัŽั‘ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั€ั‹ัˆ ะั€ั‡ั?ั… ั”ัžัˆะ„ั…ั‹  ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัŠัˆ, ัžะ„ัŽั? ั„ัŽั‘ั€ั†ั„ั€ะ„โ„– ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ ั‘ั‚ัŽัˆัŒัˆ ัั€ัƒั”ัั?ัŒัˆ ั…ะั…ั‘ ัŒัˆ. ??ั„ั€??ัˆัŒัˆั‘  ั‘ะั…ั„ัˆ ััˆั— ั?ั‹ัˆ ?ั€ั‘ัˆั‹ัˆั„ัˆั‘ ัˆ ?ั€ั‹ั…ัะ„ัˆั - ัŽัั€ ัˆั‡ ?ั‹ั…ัŠั‘ั€ัั„ะัˆัˆ. ?ัŽ ั‚ัŽั‡ัŒัŽั†ััŽ, ัั€ัˆััŽั‹ั…ั… ั‚ั‹ัˆ ะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ั?ัŒ ัˆ ั”ั‘ัั…ยฐั?ัŒ ั‡ั€?ัˆะ„ััˆัŠัŽัŒ ั„ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั— ัˆั„ั…ั‰ ั?ั‹ ?ั€ะัŠัˆัŽั - ั‚ ัั…ะัˆัŽั„ ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽั‰ ััŽั‹ัŽั‚ัˆั? ะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั†ั… ั‘ั€ัŒัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ . ?ั ัั… ั?ั‹ ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัŠัŽัŒ, ััŽ ั…ัƒัŽ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„? ัŽ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั… ั?ั‹ัˆ ัŽัžั…ัโ„– ั‘ั—ัŽั„ั? ั‘ ัˆั— ััŽั ะ„ัˆ ัŒัˆ. ?ััˆ ัะัˆั„ั…ะั†ัˆั‚ั€ั‹ัˆั‘โ„– ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ั€, ัžะ„ัŽ ะัŽั†ั„ั…ััˆ , ะ‡ัˆั‡ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั†ัˆั‡ััˆ ัˆ ั‘ัŒั…ะะ„ัˆ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€ ั‚ ั„ั…ั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ ัั… ั?ั‹ัŽ - ั?ั‹ ัะัŽั‘ะ„ัŽ ัะัˆั‡ะั€ัŠ ั„ั…ั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ. ?ั…ะัŠัŽั‚โ„– ัŒั”ั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽ ััŽะัŽั‹ั€ั‘โ„– ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ ัƒะั”ั?ั— ั‡ั€ัั‹ั”ั†ั„ั…ััˆั‰ ั„ัŽัŠั…ะ„ัˆั‡ัŒั€. ?ัŽ ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽั‰ ััŽั‹ัŽั‚ัˆัั… ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ  ั‘ัŒั…ั‹ัŽ ั‚?ั„ั‚ัˆัั”ั‹ั‘  ?ะัˆัั…ั‰, ัŠั€ัŠ ั‚ั…ั‹ัˆัŠัˆั‰ ััŽััŽะััˆัŠ ัŽะะ„ัŽั„ัŽัŠั‘ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽัƒัŽ ั”ัžั…ััˆ  ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ ั…ะั…ั‘ัˆ. ?ัƒัŽ ััŽั‹ั…ัŒัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั‰ ะ„ะั”ั„: "?ะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ ั…ะั…ั‘ั…ั‰" - ัŽั‘ัŽัั…ัััŽ ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั…ะั…ั‘ัˆ ั‘ั”?ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั”ั…ะ„ ั„ัŽ ัั€ยฐั…ัƒัŽ ั‚ะั…ัŒั…ััˆ. ?ะัˆัั…ั‰ ััŽั„ัž?ะัŠัˆั‚ั€ั…ะ„ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัั” ัŽ ั…ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ั… ?ัŽัƒั€.

?ัŽัั€ะั—ัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒ

?ั€ัŠ ัŽะ„ัŒั…ัžั…ััŽ ั‚ ั‘ั€ัŒัŽัŒ ัั€ั‡ั‚ั€ััˆัˆ ะ„ั…ัžั…ััˆ  ัŒัŽัั€ะั—ัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒ ััŽั„ัž?ะัŠัˆั‚ั€ั‹ ั…ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ัŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ (ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ัŽ "ัŒัŽัั€ะั—" ัั”ัŠั‚ั€ั‹โ„–ััŽ ัŽั‡ัั€ัžั€ั…ะ„ "ั…ั„ัˆัั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัั?ั‰ ัะั€ั‚ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–"). ? ั‘ั”?ััŽั‘ะ„ัˆ, ยคะ„ัŽ ะ„ั…ัžั…ััˆั… ัะั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั€ั‚ั‹ ั‹ัŽ ั‘ัŽััŽั‰ ะั…ั€ัŠะŽัˆ? ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ ัŒััŽัƒัŽััŽั†ัˆ  ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัŠัŽั‚ ัˆ ั„ั‚ั”ั— ััŽัƒัŽั‚ ั‚ ั…ะั…ั‘ัˆ ?ั€ะัŠัˆัŽัั€ - ?ัŽัƒั€ ?ั…ะ„ั—ัŽัƒัŽ ?ั€ั‚ั…ะ„ั€, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ัŽั ะั€ั‘ั‘ัŒั€ะ„ะัˆั‚ั€ั‹ ัŠั€ัŠ ั‡ั‹ัŽัƒัŽ ?ัŽัƒั€, ัˆ ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€ - ?ัŽัƒั€ ั‹?ัั‚ัˆ. ?ัŽั„ัŽัััŽ ัŠั€ัŠ ั‘ั‹ั”ัžั€ั…ะ„ั‘  ั‘ัŽ ัŒััŽัƒัˆัŒัˆ ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ัŽั„ั…ั‰ั‘ะ„ั‚ั”??ัˆัŒัˆ ั„ั‚ัˆั†ั…ััˆ ัŒัˆ, ัŽััŽ ั‚?ั‹ัˆั‹ัŽั‘โ„– ั‚ ัะัŽะ„ัˆั‚ัŽััŽั‹ัŽั†ัั”? ัŠะั€ั‰ััŽั‘ะ„โ„–, ัˆ ั‚ ะั…ั‡ั”ั‹โ„–ะ„ั€ะ„ั… ั‘ะ„ั€ั‹ัŽ ั…ะั…ั‘โ„–? ั‚ ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะั€  ั‚ััŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ั‘ะ„ั‚ัˆัˆ ัŽั‘ั”ั„ัˆั‹ั€ ยคะ„ัŽ ั„ั‚ัˆั†ั…ััˆั…. ?ั?ั…ั… ัั€ัะั€ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆั… ?ัŽัั€ะั—ัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒั€ ั‚ ั‡ัั€ัžัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽั‰ ั‘ะ„ั…ัั…ััˆ ัŒัŽั†ััŽ ั—ั€ะั€ัŠะ„ั…ะัˆั‡ัŽั‚ั€ะ„โ„– ัŠั€ัŠ ััŽะ??ั…ั…ั‘  ั‡ั€ ัŽัžัˆ?ั…ััˆั… ะŽั…ะัŠั‚ัˆ ัŽะ„ ัƒััŽั‘ะ„ัˆัžั…ั‘ัŠัˆั— ั”ัžั…ััˆั‰, ััŽ ัˆั‘ัะั€ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆั… ั‚?ั‡ั‚ั€ั‹ัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹โ„–ัŠัŽ ัŽัั”ั‘ะ„ัŽยฐั…ััˆ  ัˆ ัั…ั‘ััŽะ ั„ัŠัŽั‚, ัžะ„ัŽ ัˆั— ั”ั†ั… ั‚ ั‘ั‚ัŽ? ัŽัžั…ะั…ั„โ„– ั?ั‹ัŽ ัั…ัŽัั—ัŽั„ัˆัŒัŽ ัˆั‘ัะั€ั‚ั‹ ะ„โ„–. ?ัŽะโ„–ัั€ ั‘ ัŒัŽัั€ะั—ัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒัŽัŒ ัั€ัžั€ั‹ั€ั‘โ„– ั‚ ัŠัŽัะŽั… ั‚ะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆ  ัˆ ัะัŽั„ัŽั‹ั†ั€ั‹ั€ั‘โ„– ั‚ ะ„ะั…ะ„โ„–ั…ัŒ ั‘ะ„ัŽั‹ั…ะ„ัˆัˆ. ??ั‹ัŽ ั„ั‚ั€ ั‚ัˆั„ั€ ััŽั‘ั‹ั…ั„ัŽั‚ั€ะ„ั…ั‹ั…ั‰ ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั”ัžั…ััˆ : ั„ัˆัั€ัŒัˆั‘ะ„? (ัŽะ„ ัƒะ. ั‘ั‹ัŽั‚ั€, ัŽั‡ัั€ัžั€??ั…ัƒัŽ "ั‘ัˆั‹ั€"), ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ั”ัžัˆั‹ัˆ, ัžะ„ัŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ััั€  ั‘ัˆั‹ั€ ั‚ั„ัŽั—ัั”ั‹ั€ ั†ัˆั‡ัโ„– ั‚ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั… ะ„ั…ั‹ัŽ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ั€, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะัŽั… ัะั…ั„ััŽั‹ัŽั†ัˆะ„ั…ั‹โ„–ััŽ ัั… ัˆัŒั…ั‹ัŽ ั‘ั‚ัŽั…ัƒัŽ ั‘ัŽัั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽัƒัŽ, ัะัˆั‘ั”?ั…ัƒัŽ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ัˆ ัˆัŒั…ั‹ัŽ ัั”ั†ั„ั” ั‚ ัˆั‘ะ„ัˆัััŽั‰ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัžั…ั‘ัŠัŽั‰ ั„ั”ยฐั…, ัˆ "ัŒัŽั„ั€ั‹ัˆั‘ะ„?", ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั… ั‚ั…ะัˆั‹ัˆ ั‚ ัŽั„ััŽัƒัŽ ?ัŽัƒั€, ัŠัŽะ„ัŽะ?ั‰ ัŽะ„ัŠะ?ั‚ั€ั…ะ„ ?ั…ั  ะั€ั‡ั‹ัˆัžั?ัŒัˆ ัั”ะ„ ัŒัˆ.

?ะ„ัŽั? ั‡ั€?ัˆะ„ัˆะ„โ„– ั‘ั‚ัŽั‰ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ ัŽ ั…ั„ัˆััŽััŽั†ัˆัˆ, ั„ัˆัั€ัŒัˆั‘ะ„? ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัััŽ ัŽะ„ั‚ั…ะัƒั€ั‹ัˆ ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั…ัััŽั‘ะ„โ„– ?ะัˆั‘ะ„ั€, ?ัŽะ„ัŽะัŽัƒัŽ ัŽััˆ ั‘ัžัˆะ„ั€ั‹ัˆ ั‡ั€ ัะัŽั‘ะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠั€, ัˆั‡ัะั€ัััŽัƒัŽ ?ัŽัƒัŽัŒ ัŠั€ัŠ ?ั…ั‘ั‘ัˆ? ัˆ ั‚ัŽั‡ั‚?ยฐั…ัััŽัƒัŽ ั„ัŽ ั”ะัŽั‚ั  ?ัŽั†ั…ั‘ะ„ั‚ั€. ?ัŽัƒั‹ั€ั‘ััŽ ั‚ั‡ัƒั‹ ั„ั” ัŽั„ััŽัƒัŽ ัˆั‡ ัŽะ„ั‚ั…ะ„ั‚ั‹ั…ััˆั‰ ยคะ„ัŽัƒัŽ ั”ัžั…ััˆ  - ั€ั„ัŽัะŽัˆั€ััˆั‡ัŒั€, ัžั…ั‹ัŽั‚ั…ัŠ ?ัˆั‘ั”ั‘ ั„ัŽั‘ะ„ัˆัƒ ั‘ัŽั‚ั…ะยฐั…ัั‘ะ„ั‚ั€ ัˆ ั?ั‹ ั”ั‘?ััŽั‚ั‹?ั ัŠั€ัŠ ??ั ?ัŽั†ัˆั‰ ัะัˆ ?ัƒัŽ ัŠะั…?ั…ััˆัˆ.